Crime and Justice

Immigration rights protesters rally for policing policy changes in Burlington

After holding a rally outside Burlington City Hall in support of the No Más Polimigra campaign, protesters hung banners from balconies inside the City Council chambers. Photo by Sarah Asch/VTDigger

BURLINGTON — More than 130 protesters packed into the Burlington City Council meeting Tuesday night to voice their support for a resolution that would close loopholes in the state’s Fair and Impartial Policing Policy, and to express their frustration that a vote on the resolution was not on the meeting’s agenda. 

The loopholes in the policy make it easier for local law enforcement to collaborate with agencies like Immigration and Customs Enforcement by allowing local police to report the immigration status of individuals reporting crimes and allowing police to ask about a person’s immigration status if it is suspected they recently crossed the border. The policy also currently allows police to collaborate with immigrations agents in the name of “public safety” and allows immigration officials access to people in police custody.

Perri Freeman, the city councilor for the Central District who submitted the resolution for a vote, called the loopholes “inhumane” and said they make communities less safe overall.

“It discourages people from even contacting law enforcement because they’re afraid of being challenged about their status,” she said in an interview. “We want people to feel like they can trust law enforcement.” 

The effort to pass resolutions like this one across the state is known as the No Más Polimigra campaign and is being led by Migrant Justice, a migrant workers advocacy group. Polimigra is a combination of the Spanish words for police and immigration agents. Winooski is the only city to have passed a resolution of this kind to date. 

In Burlington, the No Más Polimigra effort is also supported by Community Voices for Immigrant Rights, a coalition that was created last summer to plan immigrant rights protests. Migrant Justice and Community Voices were among the organizers and co-sponsors of Tuesday’s protest along with the Vermont ACLU, 350 Vermont, and a number of other organizations.

The Burlington City Council past a Fair and Impartial Policing Policy in June 2017. The state passed its model policy in December 2017, and since then Burlington has used a combination of its policy and the state’s in accordance with state law. 

Immigration protesters
Protesters hold signs and flags on Church Street at a rally outside City Hall before the Burlington City Council meeting on Tuesday. Photo by Sarah Asch/VTDigger

Before the City Council meeting started, protesters gathered with signs and banners in the snow outside City Hall for a rally at which five speakers talked about the importance of protecting immigrants’ rights.

Asma Elhuni, who is working to have a similar resolution passed where she lives in Hartford, called on the crowd to organize politically around this issue. 

VTDigger is underwritten by:

“Human safety is not an opinion. You can’t have an opinion about human safety. This is about human rights,” she said. “We need to tell [the council] that if they don’t care about everyone in this community we’re going to organize and we’re going to remove them from their positions.” 

Rosie Alfaro, a member of the Migrant Justice coordinating committee, spoke about the fear migrants feel knowing that any encounter with local law enforcement might trigger detainment and deportation. 

“We demand that the city pass the No Más Polimigra policy so that we no longer live in fear of being detained,” she said, with Migrant Justice organizer Will Lambek acting as her translator. “We want to be able to leave our homes without the fear, without the terror, that an encounter with a police officer will result in our deportation.” 

During the rally, organizers informed the crowd that the City Council had not scheduled a vote on the resolution this month because it was not “time sensitive” compared to other agenda items. 

Ashley Smith, an organizer with Community Voices, does not believe this issue can wait for another time.  

“In our minds this is a state of emergency, and this is probably the most time sensitive social justice question in the United States today,” he said. “We’re not going to stop until this is won in the city.”

City Council President Kurt Wright capped the public comment section at one hour, although in the end it lasted closer to an hour and 20 minutes. Each speaker had two minutes to address the council, and 24 people spoke about the No Más Polimigra campaign. Many of the speakers were local college students, and several were migrant farmworkers who shared personal stories of being arrested and detained by law enforcement. 

Wright said that the vote on the resolution would be taken up at the March 9 meeting; several speakers expressed their frustration that the vote would be after the upcoming election on March 3.  

Freeman said she hopes that taking this issue to the local level helps effect statewide change during a time when the federal government is rolling back personal protections for a number of groups.

“Local law enforcement is not meant to do the job of federal immigration and customs enforcement and monitor people’s status in terms of documentation,” she said. “This is a misuse of taxpayer funds and it’s completely unequal.”

Immigration protesters
About 130 people gathered at a rally outside Burlington City Hall on Tuesday, Feb. 18, 2020, to voice support for a resolution that would make it more difficult for local law enforcement to collaborate with immigration enforcement agencies. Photo by Sarah Asch/VTDigger

Alfaro said she was encourage by local support for the resolution. Enrique Balcazar, one of the migrant workers who spoke at the meeting, expressed a similar sentiment. 

“It’s exciting to see solidarity from the residents of Burlington and Vermont,” he said, in an interview conducted in Spanish. “We are joining this movement to become a state that respects the rights of immigrants and does not invest resources to allow the police to collaborate with immigration agents to deport people.” 

Smith said that Community Voices intends to see this initiative through, even if that means reintroducing the resolution once the next city council is in session or pushing to make it the subject of a referendum. 

Stay on top of all of Vermont's criminal justice news. Sign up here to get a weekly email with all of VTDigger's reporting on courts and crime.


VTDigger's reporting on COVID-19 is going to be very important in coming weeks. If you rely on it, please donate here.

Sarah Asch

About Sarah

Sarah Asch is an intern for VTDigger covering Burlington and Chittenden County. She recently graduated from Middlebury College where she studied English literature. Previously, she has worked at the Addison Independent, the Rutland Herald and the San Francisco Public Press. She is originally from Mill Valley, California.

Email: [email protected]

Reader Footnotes

Please help move our stories forward with information we can use in future articles.

Readers must submit actual first and last names and email addresses in order for notes to be approved. We are no longer requiring readers to submit user names and passwords.

We have a limit of 1,000 characters. We moderate every reader note.

Notes about other readers’ points of view will not be accepted. We will only publish notes responding to the story.

For more information, please see our guidelines. Please go to our FAQ for the full policy.

About voting: If you see voting totals jump when you vote on comments, this indicates that other readers have been voting at the same time.
9 Comment threads
0 Thread replies
Most reacted comment
Hottest comment thread
8 Comment authors
newest oldest most voted
Frank Beardsley

I hope ICE sends a tactical team to Burlington to investigate all these people masquerading as ‘farm workers’.

Jamey Berry

Is not this the same Burlington official quoted who wants to have police officers confront criminals without weapons for protection?
Please Stop making a mockery of our rights as a nation to decide who can enter and under what conditions. I hope these people understand this behavior is a big part of why King Trump and Prince Jared are in power (and will likely be again).
Ice and Border Patrol are working hard to enforce the laws of our nation, and I hope they increase their efforts here in VT.
Prosecute those who knowingly hire illegal immigrants, which perpetuates the problem.

Tim Vincent

How many of these protesters would give total strangers (illegal aliens) full run of their homes?
And BTW, LEGAL immigrants are not total strangers, having gone through some level of vetting before admission.

Mark Lundie

So let me get this straight, your here illegally you break the law and are arrested. And we don’t want you deported? How does that make any sense. I’m all for immigration, but legal immigrants not illegal. Have most farm hands been smuggled into the country? I assumed they had work visas. A work visa means your here legally for work. Is vermont loaded with illegals or is this hype and posturing for political gain?

Paul Richards

“Freeman said she hopes that taking this issue to the local level helps effect statewide change during a time when the federal government is rolling back personal protections for a number of groups.” The federal government is not “rolling back personal protections for a number of groups”. The federal government is attempting to roll back the blatant flaunting of our laws and to uphold the laws they took an oath to do so. Forcing law enforcement officers to ignore our laws and thwart their efforts puts them in danger and rolls back personal protections for all law abiding citizens.

Karen McIlveen1

Legal immigrants have the rights of citizens.
Look to Los Angeles CA if you want to see unfettered migration at its best. Not Rodeo Drive or Hollywood, take a walk through the neighborhoods, tour the jails, stand in line for benefits, go to the non-elite clinics and hospitals, then come back to VT and we will talk “migrant justice”.

Paul Richards

On the one hand we had the 911 commission and others reveal the fact that the attack could have been prevented if only all of the state, local and federal law enforcement entities shared information and worked to stop it. As a result, they collectively failed to protect Americans. On the other hand we have a group of people demanding that local law enforcement actively thwart the efforts of federal law enforcement in their efforts to protect us and uphold the rule of law. To me this is a no brainer; these people can make all the noise they want but deserve no real consideration in their efforts to force law enforcement officers to make way for lawlessness. ALL law enforcement entities should be working together closely to enforce laws, keep us safe and protect our sovereignty. Any efforts to do otherwise are anti-American and promote an unlawful society.

Bill D’Avignon

Excuse my ignorance, but the article translates what “Polimigra” means, but what is “No Mas”? When I went to school we only had Latin, French, and Russian foreign language courses.

John Greenberg

No mas means no more. It’s from the Latin magis.


Recent Stories

Thanks for reporting an error with the story, "Immigration rights protesters rally for policing policy changes in Bu..."