Energy & Environment

Compost-feeding chicken farms fear regulatory changes will break them

Chickens eat food scraps
Chickens peck at food scraps in a compost pile at Black Dirt Farm, a chicken farm that uses food waste as feed. Photo by Justin Trombly/VTDigger

Chicken farmers who also run compost operations say a change in how they are regulated will put them out of business. 

Until last year, this small group involved in both composting and farming were viewed as farms and overseen by the Agency of Agriculture. By next November, they will have to receive solid waste permits from the Department of Environmental Conservation, a change the on-farm composters say will be costly and complicated. 

The compost and chicken farmers hope to have lawmakers keep their status as farms next session and be allowed to continue feeding chickens food scraps. And they hope the state will do more to promote in-state food waste recycling.

“It’s had a huge economic impact on us,” said Tom Gilbert, owner of Black Dirt Farm in Greensboro Bend. “The piece about not being a farm, it would basically be impossible for us to be open.”

Tom Gilbert
Tom Gilbert, owner of Black Dirt Farm in Greensboro Bend, says the permits he will need to continue to operate his chicken farm/composting business as well as the reclassification of his farm will put him out of business. Photo by Justin Trombly/VTDigger

The state Agency of Agriculture and Agency of Natural Resources have tangled for decades over who should be regulating the environmental and public health impacts of farms. Vermont is one of the only states to divvy up farm water quality regulation between its environmental and agricultural agencies. 

Vermont has a handful of farms that collect food scraps from local businesses and residents that they blend into a compost mix to feed hens. The leftovers are then processed into compost that they sell. Feeding the hens food scraps allows these farmers to make the economics work for smaller scale egg operations, where most of the costs come from feed.

This is not the first time this question of whether these businesses are farms or solid waste facilities. But Gilbert and Kurt Ericksen, general manager of Montpelier-based Vermont Compost Company, had thought the matter was settled over a decade ago.

In 2006, the Department of Environmental Conservation received a complaint about alleged stream pollution by Vermont Compost Company. Though no evidence of a violation was found, the complaint brought up a lingering question about which agency should investigate. Cathy Jamieson, solid waste program manager with DEC, clarified in a 2007 memo that her department does not regulate food waste brought to farms to feed chickens. 

Vermont Compost Company’s “use of food wastes for chicken feed is a resourceful operation, where waste that might normally end up in a landfill is eaten by chickens, which lay eggs that get sold locally,” she wrote. 

VTDigger is underwritten by:

The Agency of Agriculture, through the Attorney General’s Office, submitted a memo around the same time saying that the agency considered “the operation of an egg farm and the preparation of compost by (the Vermont Compost Company)” to be farming. 

A law passed in 2012, the Universal Recycling Law, set off a wave of waste management changes in the state. Among other requirements, the law contained a phased-in ban on food waste going to landfills, with a complete ban next year. 

Cary Giguere
Cary Giguere of the Agency of Agriculture says the agency cannot regulate the feeding of food waste to chickens. Photo by Erin Mansfield/VTDigger

As more composting businesses started in response to that law, the Agency of Agriculture started receiving odor and bird complaints about the on-farm compost facilities, said Cary Giguere, director of public health and agricultural resource management for the agency. The ag agency did not have the authority to regulate odors and other nuisance complaints on those operations. That power fell to the DEC environmental regulators.

The agriculture agency could have entered into an agreement with DEC similar to its agreement to divvy up water quality regulation but “didn’t actually have any staff or expertise to deal with some of the issues that were coming up,” said Giguere. 

“While we’re supportive of feeding chickens food scraps, it’s outside of our bandwidth to regulate that activity,” he said. 

That led Diane Bothfeld, director of administrative services for the Agency of Agriculture, to send a memo in 2018 to Jamieson, of DEC, saying that the agriculture agency was no longer going to regulate on-farm composting operations. She wrote that “it is important to note that importing ‘food residuals’” is not considered farming.

Diane Bothfeld, director of administrative services for the Agency of Agriculture, says the agency cannot regulate on-farm composting operations.

Bothfeld also wrote that the agency “has concerns” that farmers feeding chickens food plate scraps could transmit infectious diseases and farmers to comply with the updated federal food safety law. 

Giguere said in an email that the agency is neither condoning nor condemning farmers who feed chickens food scraps. “While post-consumer plate waste can’t be distributed as a commercial feed these is no current state law or policy preventing composters from allowing chickens to forage on compost piles,” he wrote. 

The agriculture agency’s memo says it will work with the seven unpermitted on-farm composting businesses to apply for a composting facility permit by next November. Jamieson said composting regulations “ensure that it is done in a way that protects public health and the environment.” 

“Because this is food waste, it can attract rodents, skunks, birds, flies and whatnot,” she said. “It needs to be managed appropriately. If it’s not done correctly it can cause odors, dust and be a real nuisance to neighbors.” 

When the change was announced, compost farmers complained that the agency had undermined a public process that began when the Agency of Agriculture met with them a couple years prior to discuss best management practices for their businesses. They were surprised when this resulted in what they feel is an about-face in how they are regulated. 

“Right now, with the policies as they’re proposed, someone from the Agency of Ag could come on-site to look … at the compost forage that we produce, which is we raise our flock on, and they would say … we do not look at this as an agricultural practice anymore,” said Ericksen of Vermont Compost Company. 

Chickens roosting
Chickens roost inside a barn at Black Dirt Farm. Photo by Justin Trombly/VTDigger

Both Gilbert and Ericksen see raising chickens as integral to the composting process on their farms, with the food waste, spent grain and pasture that the hens forage on mimicking their natural feeding habits. Black Dirt Farm even received a grant from the USDA to study the best way to safely and economically scale up this practice

The change from being regulated as a farm to a composting facility does not just entail applying for a single solid waste permit. Gilbert estimates that he would now need six additional permits beyond what he had as a farm. And he is afraid he will lose his exemptions from local zoning laws and Act 250 regulations. 

VTDigger is underwritten by:

Gilbert wrote in testimony to lawmakers last February that poultry farmers with hens foraging on compost “are facing a unique level of regulation and scrutiny compared to other farmers.” 

“My friends that are dairy farmers, they’re just so insulted looking on at what we have to do because when the Agency (of Agriculture) shows up there, it’s like they’re filling out paperwork for you to help with everything,” he said. 

Additionally, Gilbert says the way the state Agency of Natural Resources is interpreting food waste management parts of the universal recycling law is further hurting his business. 

Vermont has a food recovery hierarchy in law that prioritizes how the state will manage otherwise tossed food, with reducing food waste at the top. Feeding animals is third on the list, followed by composting and anaerobic digestion at number four. (Second is donating eligible food for human consumption.)

Black Dirt Farm had been contracted by Maine-based Agri-Cycle to collect food waste from Hannaford’s. Gilbert said there was an understanding between the two businesses that even if Agri-Cycle, which converts food waste into electricity, wanted to process the food scraps in their anaerobic digesters, they couldn’t because of how the law was written. 

Last November, Gilbert received a letter from the company saying that they were no longer contracting with Black Dirt to pick up Hannaford’s food waste because they could more cheaply send it to an out-of-state methane digester. 

“In six months we lost 30% of our business,” he said. 

Jamieson contends that the state cannot enforce the food regulation hierarchy; for example, there would be no way to require increased food waste reduction. She added that food rescue, which is when otherwise wasted food is sent to food shelves, in Vermont has almost tripled from 2014-2017

Tom Gilbert shovels compost at Black Dirt Farm in Greensboro Bend. He is the owner of the chicken farm/composting business. Photo by Justin Trombly/VTDigger

Gilbert also questions whether the state should be giving the green light to food “depackaging” systems, which mechanically separate plastic packaging from food materials. Vermont does not currently have any in-state food depackagers but Casella Waste Systems has received a draft permit for one at its Williston transfer station. 

“The problem is that fundamentally you cannot smash plastics and organic material … without getting microplastics in that material,” said Gilbert.  

Jamieson, of DEC, said depackaging systems could significantly increase food recovery, particularly from larger businesses where it may be impractical to manually separate out spoiled products from their packaging. She pointed out that a waste report last year showed that 38% of food that was thrown away in Vermont was in packaging.

But as state law requires “source separation” of food waste from other disposed items, DEC is still reviewing whether to allow non-packaged food waste to be mixed with packaged foods and sent through depackagers, Jamieson added.

After an unsuccessful effort to reverse the Agency of Agriculture’s decision last session, compost and poultry farmers worked with DEC to delay the date they would need to apply for compost facility certification to next November. 

They have been working with advocacy group Rural Vermont on policy proposals for next session. Ericksen said their main goals are to keep their businesses defined as farms and to have their compost defined as “principally produced” on-farm.

If these hoped-for changes don’t happen, Vermont Compost Company and others with similar operations have indicated they will be “stepping away from food scraps,” he said. 

A hand placing eggs in a carton
Tom Gilbert packages eggs at Black Dirt Farm in Greensboro Bend. Photo by Justin Trombly/VTDigger

Don't miss a thing. Sign up here to get VTDigger's weekly email on the energy industry and the environment.

 

VTDigger's reporting on COVID-19 is going to be very important in coming weeks. If you rely on it, please donate here.

Elizabeth Gribkoff

About Elizabeth

Elizabeth Gribkoff is VTDigger's energy and environment reporter. She graduated from UVM's Environmental Studies program in 2013, receiving departmental honors for her thesis on women's farming networks in Chile and Vermont. Since graduating, Elizabeth has worked in conservation and sustainable agriculture. Most recently, she was a newsroom and reporting intern with VTDigger.

Email: [email protected]

Reader Footnotes

Please help move our stories forward with information we can use in future articles.

Readers must submit actual first and last names and email addresses in order for notes to be approved. We are no longer requiring readers to submit user names and passwords.

We have a limit of 1,000 characters. We moderate every reader note.

Notes about other readers’ points of view will not be accepted. We will only publish notes responding to the story.

For more information, please see our guidelines. Please go to our FAQ for the full policy.

About voting: If you see voting totals jump when you vote on comments, this indicates that other readers have been voting at the same time.
1000
15 Comment threads
0 Thread replies
0 Followers
 
Most reacted comment
Hottest comment thread
15 Comment authors
newest oldest most voted
John M Farrell

This a tough situation but, personally, I would rather not buy eggs that are from chickens that eat food scraps.

Ken Egnaczak

Here we go again. Let’s hope this good idea of using food waste as livestock food before composting/anaerobic digesting doesn’t get regulated to death. We have seen enough good, productive ideas regulated to death.

Gary Miller

These local businesses are helping all of us by removing tons of food scraps from the waste stream and sequestering carbon. They provide a product that helps people all over the state avoid using polluting industrial fertilizers. Why is the state putting so much effort on going after them when industrial dairy farms are literally pouring cow manure and urine into our rivers and streams? It seems big ag has protection, and little ag doesn’t.

Tim Patterson

Black Dirt Farm is a model for the sort of ecologically responsible farm that policy makers and state agencies should encourage, not regulate out of existence. The legislature should act in the upcoming session to explicitly protect wholesome integrated farm practices like feeding chickens on compost scraps and pass H.489.
https://legislature.vermont.gov/bill/status/2020/H.489

Mark Lundie

Leave it to the government to screw up a good thing. Lets over regulate composting, and at the same time tell everyone they have to do it.

Matthew Choate

When I served in the legislature 2009-10 I learned a lot about composting on the Agriculture Committee. It was a more complicated activity than I had appreciated before serving, however I will say this. Less is more. The more ANR embeds its tentacles in regulating this, the less positive impact we will realize from composting. As Mark says, leave it over regulation to screw it up, and it will. The best thing that can happen is let the farmers and food waste generators work this out.

Tom Gilbert

To be clear on how the food scraps are used in our operations – we are attempting to mimic the decomposer system of tropical forest floors that the ancestors of modern hens’ forage. Food scraps, like fallen Oil Palm fruits, are blended at a rate of 20% with other materials that cause the mix to become microbially active, in order to foster beneficial organisms that become part of the hens’ diet. Composting is our foraging system, and also becomes our residuals management strategy like a dairy might compost is waste silage and manure.

Tom Anderson

Rearranging deck chairs on the deck of the sinking ship of Vermont. These food waste diversion composting operations are crucial to getting organic materials out of the landfills, feeding the soils which are stripped of nutrients in the current modern farms causing soil amendments that are not sustainable or environmentally friendly. Someone said they’d not like to eat eggs from chickens feeding on food waste – maybe you should look at what’s being fed to chickens in large egg and meat production – its riddled with antibiotics, poor quality and not farmed sustainably. Bureaucracy and government run amok trying to fix stuff that’s not broken and covering up all that is. Perfect.

Judith McLaughlin

Once again ANR and VTAAFM are playing “hot potato” over who has responsibility for what. In the meantime, pollution reigns in Vermont.

An entire relook, top to bottom of these 2 organizations is in order.

Vic Noble

And we continue to legislate in order to dictate vice innovate. The death of Vermont continues to draw near.

Craig H Newton

In the State of Mass. there is currently operating a food waste processing facility that takes in waste food from hospitals, restaurants, universities, stores etc.. This food waste is processed into animal feed, some of which is sold to Vermont feed manufactures. This operation is subsidized by the State. It would be costly but Vermont could do the same.

Neil Johnson

I think we’ll need to get permits for all those forest animals, bears included, doing the number one and number two in the woods.

So….what happens if a farm has a crop that goes bad? Will they need a solid waste permit to deal with the bad crop? They are really taking complete control of every possible human action in Montpelier. While they won’t openly state it, they just want complete control, all our money, just like any socialist state or kingdom.

Rich Lachapelle

Reasons to keep food scraps and yard waste out of landfills are obvious: landfill space is short and such material breaks down anaerobically there yielding the potent greenhouse gas methane. For those with any amount of land and willingness to do it, backyard composting is easy and yields high quality soil for gardening. A complicating factor for home composters is that Vermont law prohibits creating any situation which attracts bears. The more complicated problem is with those who are physically unable or who live in dwellings without some appropriate soil space. Inevitably, their organic waste will have to be hauled away to be composted. This brings up the issue of where does it get stored between pickups? Also, any law mandating that trash haulers be obligated to pick up organics necessitates truck modifications and employees with strong stomachs. Some people only have pickup every 2 weeks and in July that will make for some ripe pickings. It’s a messy issue, no doubt.

Wendy Palthey

OMG, common sense is dead. Any real farmer is first and foremost about building soil. These compost makers are part of the solution! Making soil is their main business, eggs are a by product of the business. The irony is if they wanted to put 100,000 chickens in a 100,000 sq ft house and have eggs as the main business with toxic guano over loaded soil and polluted water as a by product that is ok. That is call “agriculture”.

Laura Stone

There is very little Freedom and Personal Responsibility left in Vermont.
What you feed your own chickens on your own property is your business. This is a Free Country!
If you don’t want to buy eggs that have been fed this way then don’t buy them.
Make people aware of your practices and then let them decide, the Free Market will decide if it’s a Go or Not.
I see the word “Could” a lot there.
People have been feeding animals food scraps from restaurants forever- I’ve seen it all my life and never seen one issue.
This is Government Overreach- as usual. This is people looking for things to study and keep busy on to justify the existence of their jobs- “busy work.”
If you want to have mandatory composting then you need to have a plan for that compost and not over regulate peoples solutions and needs.
Vermont seems to want everyone to sit in a chair and wait for a check every month- this is apparently what people are voting for too- while then talking about the high cost of Government.

 

Recent Stories

Thanks for reporting an error with the story, "Compost-feeding chicken farms fear regulatory changes will break them"