Deb Snell
Deb Snell, president of AFT Vermont, addresses the Green Mountain Care Board and UVM Medical Center administrators in August. File photo by Mike Dougherty/VTDigger

[S]pringfield Hospital’s serious financial trouble has prompted state regulators to consider a host of new disclosure requirements for all Vermont hospitals.

The Green Mountain Care Board, in a new report sent to Gov. Phil Scott, details plans to require disclosure of more information, more frequently, about hospitals’ financial health. The board also is developing standards that could trigger underperforming hospitals to submit a โ€œcorrective action planโ€ to the state.

โ€œNobody wants to not be able to react in a timely enough manner if a hospital falls into financial distress,โ€ care board Chair Kevin Mullin said. โ€œAnd I think that Springfield was a wake-up call that we need to be monitoring more closely in this time where all rural hospitals across the United States are really finding intense pressures.โ€

Kevin Mullin
Kevin Mullin is the chair of the Green Mountain Care Board. File photo by Mike Dougherty/VTDigger

The regulatory discussion is spurred by last month’s revelations that Springfield Hospital hasn’t been paying its bills. The hospital’s chief executive officer and chief financial officer have resigned, and state officials have said they believe Springfield administrators omitted key informationย during budget presentations to the care board last year.

In late December, Gov. Phil Scott asked the care boardย to take a closer look at the financial health of Vermont’s small โ€œcritical access hospitals,โ€ including Springfield. The governor also said the board โ€œshould make transparent its criteria and metrics for determining the financial viability of critical access hospitals.โ€

In answering the first of Scott’s requests, the care board on Wednesday sent an โ€œinitial reassessmentโ€ of critical access hospital finances. The analysis uses actual results from hospital fiscal year 2017 and projected results from fiscal 2018; hospitals don’t have to report 2018 actuals until the end of this month.

All of that data already had been analyzed by the care board during the fiscal 2019 budget review process, and it has been available on the board’s website. So the results were โ€œnothing that we didn’t already know,โ€ Mullin said.

The report does show where each critical access hospital ranks among other hospitals for key measurements like debt service coverage ratio, operating margin and days cash on hand. The results were mixed, but Springfield โ€“ not surprisingly โ€“ fared poorly in the analysis for fiscal 2017.

A deeper dive into hospital finances is on the way in a few months: Mullin wrote to the governor that the care board โ€œintends to augment this report with additional analysis in April 2019.โ€

An image of Springfield Hospital’s entrance on its website.

Of more immediate note, the care board has created a detailed list of new financial-reporting requirements.

The board quoted a national study showing that more rural hospitals are closing. โ€œThat challenging national landscape โ€ฆ underscores the need for the state to provide enhanced focus on financial health of its critical access hospitals in particular, and all Vermont hospitals more generally,โ€ board members wrote.

โ€œThe board is therefore reassessing its metrics and data collection for hospitals to determine if there are additional metrics that might assist the state in monitoring financial health, as well as ensuring that health care costs are contained,โ€ the report says.

New disclosure proposals include:

โ€ข The care board has asked critical access hospitals to submit additional financial information based on several federal measurements that aren’t already considered by the care board. By next month, that data will be incorporated into financial โ€œdashboardโ€ summaries for each hospital.

โ€ข Officials are considering asking hospitals for โ€œsupplemental annual information.โ€ That includes information about credit ratings, parent organizations, affiliated entities and โ€œthe hospital’s financial controls, including oversight by the hospital’s board of directors.โ€

โ€ข The board will ask hospitals for more detail in periodic financial reports, โ€œsuch as balance sheet information and days cash on hand reports.โ€

โ€ข The board also is mandating that hospitals give immediate notice if certain things happen. Examples include changes in management or executive staff; violations of a loan, bond or covenant; and any โ€œsignificant negative changeโ€ in revenues or payments to employees or vendors.

โ€ข The board will consult experts to develop new measurements for hospital financial performance. Hospitals that fall โ€œbelow acceptable performance rangesโ€ would have to โ€œsubmit a corrective action plan against which the hospital could be monitored.โ€

Mike Del Trecco
Mike Del Trecco, vice president at Vermont Association of Hospitals and Health Systems. File photo by Erin Mansfield/VTDigger โ€‹

As an example of that type of monitoring, care board officials said they’re now requiring that Springfield Hospital submit additional information like weekly cash flow statements, bi-monthly accounts payable reports and monthly accounts receivable reports.

Mullin said the care board still is working through the details of new hospital-monitoring requirements, and the board’s report says it โ€œwelcomes feedback.โ€ Some of that feedback will come from the Vermont Association of Hospitals and Health Systems, which is concerned about the administrative burden of additional state reporting.

Mike Del Trecco, the association’s finance and operations senior vice president, noted that the hospital budget regulatory process already takes months.

โ€œWe’ll use our standard and long-standing approach to collaborate with the board to make sure there’s a fair balance,โ€ Del Trecco said.

Twitter: @MikeFaher. Mike Faher reports on health care and Vermont Yankee for VTDigger. Faher has worked as a daily newspaper journalist for 19 years, most recently as lead reporter at the Brattleboro...