Courts & Corrections

Jay Peak EB-5 investors sue Saint Sauveur Valley Resorts

Bill Stenger
Bill Stenger thumbs through architectural renderings of pending developments at a press roundtable in September 2013. File photo by Hilary Niles/VTDigger
Two EB-5 investors are alleging that a Canadian company “aided and abetted” the alleged fraud at Jay Peak Resort.

The investors are suing Saint Sauveur Valley Resorts Inc. for knowingly accepting $15 million in EB-5 monies as payment for Jay Peak in 2008.

Tony Sutton, an investor in Tram Haus Lodge, and an anonymous investor in Hotel Jay say that the Canadian company had knowledge of the fraud scheme and illegally accepted monies held in escrow for investors as payment for the resort in June 2008.

The two investors, through their Boston attorney, Keith Miller, are alleging that Saint Sauveur committed five securities law violations.

The claim is a new twist in the Jay Peak fraud saga. Nearly a year ago, the Securities and Exchange Commission sued Ariel Quiros and Bill Stenger, the developers of Jay Peak, for misusing $200 million in EB-5 immigrant investor funds. The Vermont Department of Financial Regulation filed a companion lawsuit against the two men. Stenger has settled with the SEC and has gone state’s evidence; Quiros has fought the federal and state charges.

The case, which doesn’t go to trial until September 2018, hinges on an allegation that a Ponzi-like scheme perpetrated by the two men started with the use of investor monies to purchase Jay Peak.

The SEC lays the blame for the transaction on Quiros and Stenger. Federal regulators did not allege that Saint Sauveur in any way participated in the illegal transfer of funds. In an affidavit, the Canadian company says that it knew nothing of Quiros’ use of EB-5 monies to buy Jay Peak.

Miller, the investors’ attorney, however, alleges that Saint Sauveur knowingly participated in an illegal funds transfer. Miller asked Michael Goldberg, the court-appointed receiver for Jay Peak, to investigate. While Goldberg investigated and considered the claim, he elected not to sue, Miller said.

Goldberg did not immediately respond to a request for comment.

The statute of limitations for a fraudulent transfer claim in a securities case is one year after federal regulators bring charges. Miller filed the lawsuit for investors on Friday, just a few days before the statute of limitations goes into effect on April 11.

Saint Sauveur started the EB-5 program at Jay Peak in 2006, two years before Quiros bought the resort. Stenger, the longtime CEO of the resort, oversaw the immigrant investor developments at Jay Peak for the Canadian company and raised $25 million from investors between December 2006 through June 2008.

In June 2008, Saint Sauveur gave Quiros control of Jay Peak in exchange for a $350,000 down payment. The Canadian company did not have “a written letter of intent or other agreement” and did not ask for proof that the Miami businessman had the money to make the $23.5 million purchase, about $8 million of which was assumed debt.

Ten days before the closing on June 23, Stenger, acting as general partner of the Tram Haus and Hotel Jay projects, signed a stock transfer agreement with Saint Sauveur. No lender was involved in the transaction, and Quiros was not asked to provide financial statements before the EB-5 stocks were transferred, according to the lawsuit.

In his dual capacities as general partner and an employee of Saint Sauveur, Stenger had signature authority for all of the escrowed EB-5 monies and authorized wire transfers to two brokerage accounts held by the Coral Gables, Florida, branch of Raymond James & Associates.

Acting on behalf of Saint Sauveur, Stenger transferred $11 million in escrowed funds for the Tram Haus from People’s United Bank in Vermont to a Raymond James account in Florida, according to the lawsuit. Then he transferred $7 million from the Hotel Jay escrow account in Vermont to another account at Raymond James.

The Raymond James branch was managed by Joel Burstein, Quiros’ former son-in-law.

A lawyer for Saint Sauveur told Burstein that the transferred money should not be used for the purchase of Jay Peak.

Stenger, however, “consciously permitted” $18 million of the escrowed EB-5 investor funds to be turned over to Quiros just days before the closing “for no known purpose,” according to the investor lawsuit.

Quiros took the money from the Saint Sauveur accounts, placed it in accounts he held under Q Resorts, then wired Saint Saveur what he owed for the closing, according to the SEC.

Miller, on behalf of the two investors, alleges that Saint Sauveur took the funds, “knowing the source.”

The attorney claims five counts of securities fraud against Saint Sauveur, including aiding and abetting the fraud, converting escrowed money for payment, breaching the company’s fiduciary duty and unjustly enriching themselves as a result of the fraudulent transfer.

Saint Sauveur Valley Resorts Inc. owns five ski resorts in the Laurentian Mountains of Quebec — Mont Saint-Sauveur, Mont Avila, Mont Olympia, Ski Morin Heights and Ski Mont Gabriel.

If you read us, please support us.

Comment Policy requires that all commenters identify themselves by their authentic first and last names. Initials, pseudonyms or screen names are not permissible.

No personal harrassment, abuse, or hate speech is permitted. Comments should be 1000 characters or fewer.

We moderate every comment. Please go to our FAQ for the full policy.

Anne Galloway

Recent Stories

  • Steve Baker

    St—– however, “consciously permitted” $18 million of the escrowed EB-5
    investor funds to be turned over to Quiros just days before the closing
    “for no known purpose,”
    Exactly…It’s been the “No Known Purpose” defense of the esteemed NEK businessman.
    “No Known Purpose” He signed wire transfers.
    “No Known Purpose” He authorized huge cost over runs.

    “No Known Purpose” He sent e-mails ignoring his Accountant.
    “No Known Purpose” He didn’t have a clue what “Quiros” was doing.

    Perhaps the investors will fare better outside the Foggy Vermont State Ethics and Justice System

    • waltermoses38

      Steve Baker, agree totally.
      I wonder how many Vermonters would like this guy handling their personal finances?

    • Paul Drayman

      Keep in mind also, that in the beginning and in the end, EB-5 is a Federal Program. Not to say that others are not culpable, but poor supervision of the funds at the federal level, opened the gate for this scheme.
      Saint Sauveur Valley Resorts Inc. must have been aware that EB-5 money could not be used for this purpose. How could all these parties have control of monies that do not belong to them?

      • Steve Baker

        We had a mountain of STATE employees supervising this

        • Paul Drayman

          I do know that the EB-5 program is managed on a state level. My point and opinion is, why should Saint Sauveur have control of an escrow account containing millions in foreign investors money (money which those investors assume is protected by the US government and to be used to finance qualifying projects)?
          Yes, at the very least the state employees were not up to the task, but $18,000,000.00 was drafted out of that escrow account and handed to Quiros, not by the state employees, but by an employee of Saint Sauveur and the Feds were never even aware of it or made no objection if it turns out that they were. In either case this is, pure and simple, lack of oversight by the Federal Government and a major flaw of the EB-5 program in how those funds are handled and who is in control.

          • Judith Henault

            Actually, the 18 million was handed to Stenger who then sent it on it’s way.

  • Michael A. Stahler

    This just looks worse every day. So sad that it was a scam to begin with. So many people were hurt.

  • Judith Henault

    It seems from this article that Stenger was VERY much involved with scam from the very beginning. I wonder if he is still working in a paid position for Goldberg?