Health Care Rally
Protesters join the group Rights and Democracy at a health care rally Thursday at the Statehouse. Photo by Erin Mansfield/VTDigger
[A]dvocates for health care reform demanded Thursday that Gov. Phil Scott denounce the Republican health care plan being debated in Congress.

They said the proposal would result in thousands of Vermonters losing insurance coverage and cost the state hundreds of millions of dollars in federal funding.

Lawmakers in Washington are considering the GOP-led plan as part of action to “repeal and replace” the Affordable Care Act signed into law seven years ago by then-President Barack Obama. The Republican plan would dismantle many parts of the ACA.

As of late Thursday, the plan was in danger of not passing the House as leaders scrambled for votes and called for a delay.

Brenda Siegel
Brenda Siegel, of Newfane, who lives with complex health conditions, speaks in favor of health care as a human right. Photo by Erin Mansfield/VTDigger
At a Statehouse rally, speakers decried the proposed cutbacks and insisted the Republican governor “stand up” and speak out strongly against the GOP plan, which could cost Vermont $200 million a year in Medicaid funding. Under the plan, many less-well-off Americans would see their insurance costs increase, while many wealthy would pay less than today.

“This isn’t a health care bill,” said Brenda Patoine, an event organizer. “In fact, it would be more properly called a wealth care bill.”

At an afternoon news conference, Scott said he has been clear in denouncing the Republican plan.

The plan “as written would be devastating for Vermont. It would cost us hundreds of millions of dollars. Thousands would be without insurance,” Scott said.

The governor said he had spoken directly to the White House about his concerns, as well as other governors “that might find themselves in the same situation we are in,” including ones in states with a similar expansion of Medicaid that Vermont had under Obamacare.

“We’re all concerned about what’s happening in Washington,” Scott said, adding that a special session of the Legislature might be needed if big cuts are made. He would not say if large cuts might make him rethink his pledge not to raise taxes; instead he encouraged Vermont lawmakers to pass a budget without any tax increases.

“We can only address what we know at this point,” he said.

Alan Ramsay
Dr. Allan Ramsay, a family doctor who formerly sat on the Green Mountain Care Board, speaks at Thursday’s rally. Photo by Erin Mansfield/VTDigger
At the rally — organized by the advocacy group Rights and Democracy — family physician Dr. Allan Ramsay said losing insurance could lead to premature deaths as well as the postponement of early and preventive care.

Ramsay served until last year on the Green Mountain Care Board. He called on the state’s hospitals and insurance carriers to help close the gap on any cuts from the feds. He said that during his tenure on the regulatory board those entities had fared well financially and could afford to maintain people’s coverage and help the state with any subsidies lost.

Ramsay said the economy, a Scott priority, would suffer if people don’t receive the medications they need in order to go to work.

In addition to maintaining current coverage, the speakers called for a national health care plan, a “Medicare for all.” They also expressed support for the bill H.248, which would provide universal primary care coverage.

Raina Lowell
Raina Lowell, a peer advocate for opiate addicts. Photo by Erin Mansfield/VTDigger
A major concern with the Republican bill in Congress is the potential elimination of coverage for addiction recovery.

At the rally, Raina Lowell said she could not have broken her addiction to heroin and crack cocaine without adequate medical insurance. She went into recovery in 2011 and said it was important “to send a message that their lives matter.”

Brenda Siegel said her illness required $18,000 in medication annually. She and others spoke of health care as a right and not a privilege.

“We’re responsible for one another,” she said.

Twitter: @MarkJohnsonVTD. Mark Johnson is a senior editor and reporter for VTDigger. He covered crime and politics for the Burlington Free Press before a 25-year run as the host of the Mark Johnson Show...

11 replies on “Advocates look to put Scott on the spot over health care”