This commentary is by Justin Neuman, a professor of literary studies at Eugene Lang College, The New School, and a developer of philosophical software. 

As a parent, teacher, builder and endurance athlete, I’ve spent much of my life doing — and encouraging others to do — hard things. I believe in the value of work. So why, in Montpelier and in Washington, do we have a tax code that penalizes it?

According to the Congressional Budget Office, individual income and payroll taxes supplied more than 80% of federal revenue in 2026. In Vermont, personal income tax provides more than half of general fund revenue. In the most capital-rich society the world has ever seen, the government runs largely by leeching off human paychecks.

Here’s a vivid example. SpaceX advertised salaries of $90,000 to $160,000 for an executive assistant. Every paycheck is taxable income. Elon Musk, meanwhile, like any equity billionaire, can finance his lifestyle on loans by pledging shares as collateral. A loan isn’t taxed as income, so he can legally get cash without selling stock or paying tax on the gains for as long as he likes. “Buy, borrow, die,” as the estate planners tell their richest clients. His assistant, however, has to pay taxes on every check.

The asymmetry between owners and earners is about to get even more consequential, at least according to the stock market. The high share prices of global tech firms and historic valuations of SpaceX, OpenAI and Anthropic are, in part, wagers on replacement: that computers and robots will perform an ever-expanding range of the work once done by people, at margins no payroll can match. If companies produce more with fewer employees, returns grow while workers’ share of production shrinks. Anthropic and Nvidia are cases in point, with both companies generating more than $5 million in revenue per employee. I propose turning the current system on its head.

I call my plan a humanist tax code because it puts people and work first. Work, at its best, confers competence, builds responsibility and weaves people into the fabric of a community; it’s where many people find dignity and purpose. A check, on its own, gives a person none of that. A tax code can’t give life meaning, but it can stop charging people extra for pursuing meaning in their lives.

My proposal only asks one thing of the government: Count income consistently, whether it comes from people, companies or computers, and regardless of whether it arrives by paycheck, brokerage account or bequest.

One tax for all, and for all a fair tax.

Here’s how it would work.

First, eliminate federal income tax on the first $64,000 of income, from any source, for everyone. A hedge fund manager in New York and a carpenter in Vermont both work. The fund manager shouldn’t be taxed differently from the carpenter just because their pay arrives as a share of client gains rather than as a wage for working hours. A humanist tax code shouldn’t be focused on the rich or the poor; the goal is to make work more rewarding across the income spectrum.

Second, above that exemption, wages, capital gains, dividends and business income should face the same progressive schedule, without a discount for capital gains, but also without double jeopardy on corporate income. Gains should be taxed when they’re realized, the same way we tax a paycheck. That’s less radical than it sounds; the Tax Reform Act of 1986, signed by President Ronald Reagan, taxed gains and wages at the same top rate of 28%.

Third, treat inheritances as income to the people who receive them, above a large lifetime exemption. Today, by one estimate, inherited income is taxed at less than one-seventh the average rate on income from work. I have nothing against parents’ leaving their home, farm or savings to their children, but inherited wealth beyond that is a gain to the recipient and should be taxed as such.

Finally, there are two things a humanist tax code shouldn’t touch. First, Social Security and Medicare, including the payroll taxes that support them: These are withholdings paid by the people who will use the services, and that bargain is worth keeping visible rather than folding into the general fund. Second, the safety net: Rewarding work is not the same as punishing joblessness, and the people who can’t work, or whose labor isn’t paid, would lose nothing under my plan.

Could this replace the $3.2 trillion the federal income taxes raise today? That’s the essential question. With a taxable base of around $10 trillion, my proposal would need an effective rate of around a third. Under one model of this progressive schedule, anyone earning $50,000, like a carpenter or first-year teacher in a Vermont public school, would owe no federal income tax, instead of the roughly $4,000 they pay today. A school principal earning $100,000 would owe around $5,000, less than half the roughly $13,000 they pay under the current system. At the top end, however, a hedge fund manager earning $5 million a year with a second home in Vermont would owe more than $2 million in taxes, almost double what they likely pay under the current system.

I teach literary studies, so I’m a humanist by profession. I’m also a capitalist. I believe in the ingenuity and ambition of people. Actual humans. A market economy should encourage people to build things, solve problems, take risks and improve their circumstances, rather than concentrating capital among an ever-smaller group of owners. At the state and national level, a humanist tax code would stop treating work as something to tax and start treating it as something worth rewarding.