Energy & Environment

State fines energy company $57,500 for violations at Ludlow solar project

public utility commission members
From left, Vermont Public Utility Commissioners Margaret Cheney, Anthony Roisman, and Sarah Hofmann. Photo by Mike Dougherty/VTDigger

The Vermont Public Utility Commission has fined the Florida-based energy company NextEra $57,500 for violating its operating certificate at the largest solar development in Vermont. 

Coolidge Solar — a subsidiary of NextEra that operates a 20-megawatt solar electric generation facility in Ludlow and Cavendish — was cited for three violations of its certificate of public good, including installing above-ground power cables, conducting drilling and using unapproved equipment.

The PUC’s report found that the Coolidge facility installed more than 8,000 linear feet of power cables above ground, instead of burying them. It also used nine 2.7-megawatt inverters when the project was approved to use 14 inverters with a capacity of 1.67 megawatts each. Posts at the project were installed by drilling into the ground or rocks, instead of the “the approved method of driving the posts into the ground with the potential use of ground screws or pins,” according to the PUC's report.

In an emailed statement to VTDigger, NextEra spokesperson Bryan Garner wrote that the company did not compromise safety, despite the noncompliance.

“NextEra Energy Resources regrets not seeking prior approval from the Public Utilities Commission before making changes to the Coolidge solar plant that differed from the requirements for project design and construction,” he wrote. “At no time was safety compromised and the plant was designed and constructed pursuant to all applicable safety codes and standards.”

“Our company has made changes to its construction processes and procedures to ensure full compliance with all applicable conditions of plant design and construction,” Garner added.

Vermonters for a Clean Environment, a group headed by longtime Vermont anti-wind advocate Annette Smith, filed a complaint with the PUC in 2019 questioning whether the project was meeting its requirements. Smith said the organization received a tip through its Facebook page.

The Vermont Department of Public Service recommended a $70,000 fine based on the three violations, but the PUC settled on the $57,500 penalty.

“On the one hand, I was pleased to see that the department and the PUC stepped up to ask for a huge fine,” Smith said. “However, in the grand scheme of things, for a company NextEra, this is pocket change. This is the cost of doing business.”

Ludlow Town Manager Scott Murphy said the town was surprised to see the penalty.

“All I can say is, they’ve been a really good neighbor for us,” Murphy said. “The community benefited quite a bit from the construction of the project.”

The electricity and renewable energy tax credits produced by the Coolidge project are sold to Connecticut utilities.

NextEra, which bills itself on its website as the “world’s largest producer of wind and solar energy,” operates numerous other large energy projects around New England. It has filed a petition for a certificate of public good for a 15-megawatt solar project in Brandon.

“This is an extraordinarily wealthy corporation, and they should know better,” Smith said. “They should play by the rules.”

Don't miss a thing. Sign up here to get VTDigger's weekly email on the energy industry and the environment.


Jasper Goodman

About Jasper

Jasper Goodman is a rising sophomore at Harvard University, where he is a news and sports reporter for the Harvard Crimson, the school's independent student daily newspaper. A native of Waterbury and a 2018 graduate of Harwood Union High School, Jasper previously spent five years as a sports correspondent for the Barre-Montpelier Times Argus. For eight years, he made weekly appearances on WDEV Radio with hall-of-fame broadcaster Ken Squier. He also spent two summers as the radio play-by-play voice of the Vermont Mountaineers baseball team. In 2018, he was a summer journalism intern at The Hill newspaper in Washington, D.C.


Send us your thoughts

VTDigger is now accepting letters to the editor. For information about our guidelines, and access to the letter form, please click here.


Recent Stories

Thanks for reporting an error with the story, "State fines energy company $57,500 for violations at Ludlow solar pro..."
  • Hidden
  • Hidden
  • This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.