Rutland challenged to include women on city marketing panel

Rutland

Downtown Rutland. Wikimedia Commons photo by Sfoskett

RUTLAND — Vanessa Robertson, a former member of Rutland’s Board of Aldermen, said that a committee formed to market the city lacks representation from an important constituency: women.

“After looking at committee assignments I realized there was a major issue in regards to the marketing committee,” Robertson told the board during the public comment portion of the meeting Monday night.

“The marketing committee is made up of only three people, and all of which are men,” Robertson said. “It concerns me that there are absolutely no women on this committee. It seems to me that you would want someone to represent the 51 percent of society.”

Robertson talked of the $100,000 commitment the city has contributed to a $200,000 regional marketing effort currently underway, which involves several other communities, businesses and organizations.

She said with the city being the largest single contributor to the initiative, the city’s marketing committee will have a great deal of influence.

“I hope to see an alderwoman added to this committee,” Robertson said, “not only because it is a large investment, but because women, such as myself, deserve representation on a committee that markets the city.”

The city’s marketing committee includes three members of the Board of Aldermen: Christopher Ettori, the committee’s chairman, and Timothy Cook and Ed Larson.

No board members spoke after Robertson made her comments. However, as the meeting drew to a close, board President Sharon Davis, who appoints members to committees of the board, did address the issue.

Davis said any member of the Board of Aldermen can attend any meeting of its committees.

“You may not be voting, but you certainly have a voice,” Davis said.

There are four women on the 11-member Board of Aldermen. The marketing committee is the only board panel that does not have a woman on it.

Davis said that when she sets up a committee, she doesn’t look at people’s gender, but instead their experience and interest they have expressed about a particular topic or area of city government.

“As a woman … I’m comfortable with that,” Davis told the board. “We work as a unit. We work as a team, and we’ve got a lot work to do to move this city forward.”

Lisa Ryan, a board member, then asked if that meant no women would be added to the marketing committee. Davis replied that the marketing committee’s makeup would not be changing.

After the meeting, Robertson said she was disappointed no women would be added to the marketing panel. Most city committees, she said, are made up of five board members, so adding two to the marketing committee, including at least one woman, would not make it any larger than most city panels.

“It’s a very easy fix to add women to this committee,” Robertson said.

Robertson is the youngest person ever elected to the board, at age 21. She served one year and did not seek re-election in March because she will be attending the University of New Hampshire School of Law in the fall.

In other business Monday night, the board unanimously approved with no debate the use of $200,000 from the city’s Zamias fund to help offset costs associated with a nearly $1 million project to create a Center Street Marketplace in a downtown alley. The Zamias fund is money the city receives in impact fees from the developers of the Diamond Run Mall in Rutland Town.

Alderman Larson also asked that the board conduct a review of the city charter to make it gender-neutral. In many places, he said, the charter contains the word “he” when referring to positions, such as the police chief. The board unanimously approved sending the matter to its Charter and Ordinance Committee to conduct that review.

Alan J. Keays

Comment Policy

VTDigger.org requires that all commenters identify themselves by their authentic first and last names. Initials, pseudonyms or screen names are not permissible.

No personal harrassment, abuse, or hate speech is permitted. Be succinct and to the point. Comments should be 1000 characters or fewer. If your comment is over 500 words, consider sending a commentary instead.

We personally review and moderate every comment that is posted here. This takes a lot of time; please consider donating to keep the conversation productive and informative.

The purpose of this policy is to encourage a civil discourse among readers who are willing to stand behind their identities and their comments. VTDigger has created a safe zone for readers who wish to engage in a thoughtful discussion on a range of subjects. We hope you join the conversation. If you have questions or concerns about our commenting platform, please review our Commenting FAQ.

Privacy policy
  • Michael Taub

    “You may not have a vote, but you have a voice.” Good one….

  • Christopher Ettori

    Just to add some additional background…The marketing committee is a select committee that was created by the board about a year and a half ago after a proposal by former Alderman Matt Bloomer and myself. We had discussed the need for the city to be able to spread the word about what was happening in the city and help showcase some of our successes. For instance, we used half the revenue from solar farm leases within the city to fund a business incentive program through the Rutland Redevelopment Authority. This program provides small grants, small forgivable loans, and access to larger loans through a partnership with Heritage Family Credit Union for qualified businesses looking to start up or expand in the city. The story of reinvesting revenue for economic development is an example of a story we need to promote.

    And last summer we brought all of our city and regional economic development entities together to discuss how we can partner to promote the city. They came back a month later with a proposal for the regional marketing initiative. The $100,000 funding provided was actually approved through the Community & Economic Development committee chaired then by Alderman Davis. Also, our influence on the regional marketing initiative is through our liaison Matt Bloomer and not the marketing committee specifically.

    Our vision was always that this committee would be more of a working committee rather than a policy committee. I would be glad to share the work with any other board members interested, particularly the very capable and forward thinking alderwomen that I ran with this year.

    And for what it’s worth, gender equality is not the biggest issue on this committee…

  • wendywilton

    This is a much ado about nothing.

    The marketing committee is an ad hoc committee and any decision will need to go through the full board. Any member of the Board may participate in the meetings of the committee or engage in oversight on the marketing plans. The Board president, a woman, appointed members who expressed interest in the topic to the three person committee. I would think that would be the first criteria–interest and knowledge in the topic.

    At the same meeting, A male senior member of the Board referred updating the charter language to committee to make it gender neutral. To me, that is a more important issue regarding bias than is the composition of a three person committee that has no real power.

  • Gary Dickinson

    Woman sets up panel with no women on it. Woman objects.

  • JustinTurco

    Oh my gosh. Some people have too much time on their hands. 3 men, 3 women, one woman two men, two women one man………the fact that you have to give this kind of thing attention in today’s world is pathetic. Changing the city’s charter to eliminate the word he…..we are all “mankind”. And we all know that this type wording implies both men and women. Thanks for bringing this to our attention Mr. Kaeys.

Thanks for reporting an error with the story, "Rutland challenged to include women on city marketing panel"