Advocates say state isn’t doing enough to provide services for Vermonters who are deaf or hard of hearing

Austine School and the Vermont center for the deaf and hard of hearing.  Photo by Zachary P. Stephens/Brattleboro Reformer

The Austine School in Brattleboro. Photo by Zachary P. Stephens/Brattleboro Reformer

A long-existing Hearing Advisory Council will be renamed and repurposed to ensure that the State of Vermont is providing the services children and adults who are deaf or hard of hearing need through all stages of their lives.

Lawmakers began hearing concerns about services for the deaf community after the closure last year of the Austine School for the Deaf and the Center for the Deaf and Hard of Hearing in Brattleboro, Sen. Anthony Pollina, P/D-Washington, said.

“I started getting calls from parents saying ‘We have to make sure we get the services our kids need,’” since the Austine School in Brattleboro closed, said Pollina.

While it’s unlikely that Vermont will open a school for the deaf any time soon, Pollina said there may be a way to create programs for deaf children — perhaps hosted at one of the state’s colleges.

Pollina sponsored a bill that sought to establish a commission and a “bill of rights” for people who are deaf or hard of hearing this past session, S.66.

The Senate Government Operations Committee took testimony from people within the deaf community and advocates about the effect the closing of the Austine School and the center had on the deaf community in Vermont. The bill passed the Senate, but stalled in the House.

While the bill did not end up becoming law, there is a compromise being worked out now by the administration to expand an existing council into a body that would have members of the deaf community included.

The Shumlin administration is in the final stages of expanding the mission of the Hearing Advisory Council, according to Aly Richards, deputy chief of staff and director of intergovernmental affairs for the governor.

“We want to make sure that everyone is at the table and that services are continuing in an appropriate fashion,” Richards said.

Following the closure of the Austine School, the Agency of Education contracted with the Nine East Network educational company to provide school-based and parent/infant programs for students who are deaf or hard of hearing.

Susan Kimmerly, director of Nine East Network, said the closure of the state’s only school for deaf students is “the main lightning rod.”

“What we’ve tried to do this year is replicate what was provided, and at the same time, we’ve been reviewing our services so that we can address the issues that were brought up with S.66,” said Kimmerly.

Mary Essex, president of the Vermont Association of the Deaf, speaking through an interpreter on Friday, said when the Austine School and the center closed last year, many services, as well as jobs, for deaf and hard of hearing adults went away. “A lot of people in the deaf community got laid off,” she said.

There was a misunderstanding at the state level that the Austine School only served children, Essex said. The school also served as a center for services for Vermont’s deaf and hard of hearing community.

“They were all housed in the same spot,” said Essex. “It was not just a school program … It was everything.”

Essex said many groups in Vermont, from gays and lesbians to Native Americans, have representation at the state level. But deaf people, she said, are treated like second-class citizens. “Where is the deaf program? They don’t have any,” she said.

While the association is hopeful that a renamed council with expanded membership will address concerns in the short term, they still want to see S.66 advance through the House in the second year of the biennium, Essex said.

“They need to study these issues that are going on,” Essex said.

The administration’s plans to expand the council and appoint more members, Essex said, will be “a temporary stepping stone to try to get everybody on the same page.”

The deaf community is advocating for a cradle-to-grave program for people who are deaf and hard of hearing in Vermont. “We want to be first-class citizens,” and ensure access to services across all ages, she said.

Essex said parents of many deaf children have left Vermont since the Austine School closed, to ensure their children receive the best education possible.

Evelyn Dixon of Berlin, whose son, Paxton, 4, was born deaf, said Friday that concerns for parents are deep. She and her fiance, Zach Sherman, and their two sons, are moving to Maryland in a few months.

Dixon said Paxton has been receiving services since he was six months old, and has a one-on-one communication facilitator, who is deaf, as well.

Their family is relocating because Paxton has no opportunity to socialize with other deaf children.

“Vermont needs some sort of deaf program so that deaf children can interact with one another freely and not be isolated,” said Dixon. “We are moving this August so that he can attend a deaf school; it’s best for his education, we feel. We are moving to the Frederick, Maryland area — it’s considered one of the best schools for deaf children in the country.”

Dixon said, “There’s absolutely nothing in Vermont.”

The Hearing Advisory Council is being asked to report back to the Legislature by mid-January, with the following:

• An assessment of the education services and resources available;

• Any losses or reductions in services or resources due to the closure of the Austine School and the center;

• Any attempts to restore services;

• An assessment of the risks and benefits of mainstreaming;

• The feasibility of establishing a centralized school;

• Any recommendations for alternative methods of ensuring that children of the deaf community are not socially isolated and have adequate opportunities for direct contact with language or communication mode peers; and,

• A recommendation on whether the General Assembly should adopt a Bill of Rights specific to the deaf community.

Amy Ash Nixon

Comment Policy requires that all commenters identify themselves by their authentic first and last names. Initials, pseudonyms or screen names are not permissible.

No personal harrassment, abuse, or hate speech is permitted. Be succinct and to the point. Comments should be 1000 characters or fewer. If your comment is over 500 words, consider sending a commentary instead.

We personally review and moderate every comment that is posted here. This takes a lot of time; please consider donating to keep the conversation productive and informative.

The purpose of this policy is to encourage a civil discourse among readers who are willing to stand behind their identities and their comments. VTDigger has created a safe zone for readers who wish to engage in a thoughtful discussion on a range of subjects. We hope you join the conversation. If you have questions or concerns about our commenting platform, please review our Commenting FAQ.

Privacy policy
  • paul poirier

    Representative Leigh Dakin of Chester and I introduced legislation to require insurance companies to cover hearing aids as part of standard health care policy. It is clear to Leigh and I that loss of hearing is a major health issue and a major part of maintaining a good quality of life. This issue is of outmost importance to individuals who lack access to hearing because they cannot afford the cost of the products.

    • Patty Sue Cooper

      A hearing aid will not help me or my auditory processing disability. I cannot even contact state offices or places to help as most use only tty or video relay and I use my computer and text and have no phone or tty. SO I cannot hear well or process what I hear, and have no access but to call, explain the situation, and get no accommodation or help. Social agencies who help abuse victims only tty, even the ones who I tried to contact for help phone fax or tty. I have none of those. so how about working on the communication issues too. I can email some, but then there is a long wait, or no reply or just being told to call even sometimes. HELLO I AM CALLING NOW CAN YOU HEAR ME? That is about as effective as the choices they give me… Feds really ought to come in and look at this state, the discrimination is rampart.

Thanks for reporting an error with the story, "Advocates say state isn’t doing enough to provide services for ..."