Shumlin signs 'patent troll' bill aimed at protecting Vermont businesses against false claims

Shumlin signs ‘patent troll’ bill aimed at protecting Vermont businesses against false claims

Gov. Peter Shumlin signing a patent abuse protections bill into law today at the Vermont Chamber Business and Industry EXPO in South Burlington. Peter Kunin, intellectual property lawyer at Downs Rachlin Martin, PLLC, to his right, Betsy Bishop, president of the Vermont Chamber of Commerce, to his near left, and Jerry Tarrant, chief financial officer at MyWebGrocer, to his far left. Photo by Johnny Herrick/VTDigger

Gov. Peter Shumlin signs a patent abuse protections bill into law at the Vermont Chamber Business and Industry EXPO in South Burlington today. Behind Shumlin, left to right, are Peter Kunin, intellectual property lawyer at Downs Rachlin Martin, Betsy Bishop, president of the Vermont Chamber of Commerce, and Jerry Tarrant, chief financial officer at MyWebGrocer. Photo by John Herrick/VTDigger

Attorney General Bill Sorrell has a strong message for people who file baseless patent-infringement lawsuits against Vermont businesses:

“You are going to have a fight on your hands,” Sorrell said.

Gov. Peter Shumlin signed the nation’s first patent abuse protections bill into law Wednesday at the Vermont Chamber Business and Industry EXPO in South Burlington.

By amending the consumer protection law to include Vermont businesses targeted by illegitimate claims of patent infringement, the law will provide businesses with legal tools to defend against so-called “patent trolls.”

H.299, which takes effect July 1, will increase the cost and risk of pressing a baseless claim of patent infringement against Vermont companies.

“What this bill will do is protect Vermont businesses from unscrupulous people who take advantage of our businesses here in Vermont based on bad faith claims of patent infringement,” Shumlin said.

Trolls often file baseless claims hoping to force companies to pay a licensing fee to settle the claim out of court.

Shumlin said that patent trolls have targeted several Vermont businesses, such as MyWebGrocer, a provider of digital solutions for the grocery industry.

“We don’t want those businesses to be the victims of unscrupulous people who file bogus suits and then hope that our companies would rather settle out of court to get this bogus claim behind them than actually go through the expensive and lengthy process of winning the case under merits, which they would,” he said.

He added that this is a pioneering piece of state legislation.

“After I sign this law, we’ll be the first state in the country that makes this a violation of state law,” he said.

Rep. Bill Botzow, D-Bennington, who co-sponsored the bill, said that he and other members of the Committee on Commerce and Economic Development received testimony from Vermont companies frustrated by patent trolls.

“They basically say, ‘We will go away if you pay us a certain amount of money,’” Botzow said. “It’s like fishing on steroids.”

Though the law will still allow for legitimate claims of patent infringement in accordance with federal law, it will require a more detailed allegation in the licensing demand letter and increases the potential cost of making a baseless claim.

“We have put up some significant hurdles,” Botzow said.

Under the law, demand letters must include detailed information about how the Vermont product, service or technology infringes on an existing patent. The demand letter must also allow for a reasonable amount of time for the licensing fee to be paid.

The penalty for a bad faith claim is a bond equal to the cost of litigating the claim for the Vermont company.

Trolls also risk being brought into court in violation of state law. The attorney general can now file suit against patent trolls who target Vermont companies with illegitimate claims.

Sorrell said the law gives the state a valuable tool to protect businesses in addition to the state’s existing Consumer Protection Act.

“This will give us another arrow in the quiver, if you will, to fight those patent trolls who prey on Vermont businesses and organizations,” Sorrell said.

In fact, the Attorney General’s Office has been quick to use this tool. Tuesday, it filed suit against MPHJ Technology Investments, LLC, a Delaware corporation, which allegedly sent bad faith demand letters to at least two Vermont businesses, demanding a payment of $1,000 per employee, Sorrell said.

Sorrell said that he hopes the law will send a strong message to patent trolls around the country.

“To our knowledge, this is the first lawsuit of this sort filed anywhere in the country,” he said. “We are proud to have filed it.”

Rep. Paul Ralston, D-Middlebury, who spearheaded the bill, said Vermont is one of the most innovative states in the country, issuing more patents per capita than any other state.

Ralston said that the law will protect startup businesses that are often fearful of receiving abusive and bad faith assertions of patent infringement.

“Those businesses have been under threat,” he said. “And now, people can come to Vermont, they can innovate in Vermont and they can know that their government has their back.”

Ralston said businesses should be confident in their new security.

“This practice won’t happen in Vermont,” he said. “That’s how simple this is.”

Correction: An earlier version of this story said the patent troll law is under Vermont’s Consumer Protection Act. It is not. The story was updated to reflect that change.

John Herrick

Comment Policy requires that all commenters identify themselves by their authentic first and last names. Initials, pseudonyms or screen names are not permissible.

No personal harrassment, abuse, or hate speech is permitted. Be succinct and to the point. Comments should be 1000 characters or fewer. If your comment is over 500 words, consider sending a commentary instead.

We personally review and moderate every comment that is posted here. This takes a lot of time; please consider donating to keep the conversation productive and informative.

The purpose of this policy is to encourage a civil discourse among readers who are willing to stand behind their identities and their comments. VTDigger has created a safe zone for readers who wish to engage in a thoughtful discussion on a range of subjects. We hope you join the conversation. If you have questions or concerns about our commenting platform, please review our Commenting FAQ.

Privacy policy
  • Gary Trachier

    I am puzzled about a process-related aspect of this article. I hope someone can enlighten me.

    As I understand it, the chronology of events are:
    Tuesday – The Attorney General’s office filed suit against MPHJ Technology Investments, LLC.
    Wednesday – Governor Shumlin signed the bill into law.
    1 July – The law goes into effect.

    How is it that a suit can be filed which is based on a law that is not yet in effect, much less signed into law?

    • Karl Riemer

      You are right to be puzzled. The assertion in the article is erroneous. The lawsuit filed by AG Sorrell, as I understand it, alleges simple fraud without reference to the provisions of this bill, against a company whose claims are, shall we say, unsophisticated enough to be deflected without recourse to it.

  • Lee Stirling

    In the light of this newly signed bill, what shadows does it cast on Magic Hat’s highly publicized suit of that new Kentucky brewery for infringing on it’s #9 brand? I realize this isn’t a patent issue, but one of trademark infringement instead. Has there been any research done into whether any VT businesses have played the role of “patent troll”?

  • J. Scott Cameron

    All in all this is a good bill. Kudos to Bill Sorrell and Governor Shumlin for their leadership on this. Among other things, patent trolls give the entire legal profession a bad name.

  • Walter Carpenter

    “All in all this is a good bill.”

    I agree. This is a good bill. The companies doing this patent patrolling seem like the typical shakedown artists. It is good that Vermont is hitting back at them.

Thanks for reporting an error with the story, "Shumlin signs ‘patent troll’ bill aimed at protecting Ver..."