Editor’s note: Responses of Wendy Wilton, candidate for state treasurer, for the Vermont-NEA board of directors’ meeting on June 2 (Wilton had a conflict and could not attend the interview).
The immediate past
[Background if needed by the candidate] In 2009, Vermont-NEA worked with the treasurer and legislative leaders to address concerns over state funding the State Teachers Retirement System. The state, stemming largely from the governor’s proposed budgets (both Govs. Howard Dean and Jim Douglas), failed during the prior 20 years to appropriate sufficient funds for it, relying on the flawed argument that the level of investment returns justified not following actuarial recommendations. As treasurer, Jim Douglas and then Jeb Spaulding routinely warned the Legislature that a day of reckoning would result from this chronic underfunding. The agreement we all reached had the following basic features: (1) an increase in the contribution to the system of active teachers, and (2) shifting to the so-called “Rule of 90,” in exchange for (3) increasing the potential pension from 50 percent to 60 percent of a teacher’s average final compensation, (4) an increase in the annual “multiplier” from 1 2/3 percent to 2 percent after 20 years, and (5) the availability of 80 percent state premium contribution for health coverage for the teacher and her spouse.
What is your assessment of the 2009 agreement reached regarding the future of the State Teachers Retirement System? In particular, to what extent do you believe the financing of the system is now secure? What is your view of the extent to which the state should vary from actuarially recommended annual funding of the system?
Wilton response: I read with interest the recommendations developed in 2009 and the final reforms adopted, which differed slightly. While the agreement did reduce the ARC and was movement in the right direction, the 2011 valuation indicates there is more work to be done. Funded status, even after the improvements, is under 70 percent and has declined rapidly over the last decade. This is not just about lackluster market performance but it is also about demographics and increased expectations for the pension to fund greater benefits without also expecting greater inputs. The improvements made in the 2009 agreement have been overtaken by these other pressures.
The employees and the state can no longer ignore the funding requirements outlined by the actuary without long-term consequences.
The present
The current health benefit in the Teachers Retirement System has no funding source apart from the investment fund itself. The cost of the health benefit rises each year with an increase in the number of retirees along with whatever premium increase occurs. Federal tax law has implications for pension funds if more than 25 percent of what is paid out goes for purposes other than pension payments themselves. We are bumping up against that level. What should the state do to address this problem?
Wilton response: Like many other states, Vermont provided greater benefits for retirees, often in lieu of increasing pay, without fully understanding the gravity of those future obligations. In hindsight it was a mistake for the state to agree to offer retiree health care (OPEB) funded from the pension fund. Retiree health care obligations, to a greater degree than pension obligations, represent a significant and rapidly growing liability, due to historical cost increases in health care. Due to the risk of these rapidly rising costs GASB now requires these obligations be stated on the government-wide statement of net assets. GASB will require full disclosure of unfunded pension liabilities as well on the government-wide statement of net position beginning with FY 2013.
If a universal health care system were in place in the near future, it would be likely that the liability for the teacher’s retiree health care obligation would become a general liability of the state and would be shown along with the liability for all participating Vermonters. Depending upon what types of sustainability tests GASB may require in the future these liabilities may impact the financial statements or at the very least be disclosures of interest to the bond rating agencies. It is unknown at this time if such a system is sustainable. If it is not, any deficits will have a serious impact on the fiscal health of the state as a whole, creating risk and reducing the ability of the state to provide adequate annual funding to sustain the pension plans. There is great uncertainty around the issue of reform and what impacts it may have on the state’s financial sustainability, or the ability to provide like benefits to groups such as public employee retirees.
In the short term it would be very difficult to eliminate these benefits for retirees that are expected to retire in five years and less. Yet it is obvious that if the health care benefit is not reduced, or another funding source is found (or both), the OPEB burden puts the entire pension at risk, as you have noted.
A rational solution might be to stage health care benefit reductions over time for future retirees (retiring in five years or more). Examples might include elimination of the benefit after the retiree reaches Medicare-eligible age of 65, and later to eliminate the spousal benefit. Additionally, it may be necessary for retirees to pay more than 20 percent of the cost of coverage if benefit reductions do not work to relieve the liability burden in the pension fund to acceptable levels. There should be a goal to eliminate these obligations from the pension plan to the greatest degree possible.
There is virtually no health benefit attached to the Municipal Employees Retirement System. Most of those employees are, in fact, school employees. What should the state do to address this issue?
Wilton response: The state should not take on this additional burden in the teachers’ pension fund, but allow retirees to convert to Medicare at age 65, and work to reduce the cost of health care coverage outside the pension fund for early retirees before they become Medicare eligible.
The future
There will always be pressure about public pensions, particularly as private employers have dropped their retirement plans. What should be the policy of the State of Vermont regarding providing for the retirement of its public servants? In particular, should the state be considering shifting some or all public employees from defined benefits to some form of defined contribution?
Wilton response: The longer the state waits to make necessary funding improvements, the greater the debt grows, illustrating the power of compound interest (in reverse). Eventually these burdens of the pension liabilities and the OPEB component, will “crowd out” other necessary budgetary items. An example of this would be a reduction in transfers from the General Fund to the Education Fund, which was witnessed in the development of the FY 2013 budget this year due to General Fund shortfalls. This was in fact a way for the state to fund some of the pension costs from the Ed Fund, by reducing the transfer.
I believe that it is a sound idea to keep the defined benefit (DB) plan going, because it does provide a desirable benefit that helps Vermont compete for and retain qualified educators. Yet, it will take commitment from the employees and the state to fund it correctly in order to ensure its sustainability.
I believe that it is a sound idea to keep the defined benefit (DB) plan going, because it does provide a desirable benefit that helps Vermont compete for and retain qualified educators. Yet, it will take commitment from the employees and the state to fund it correctly in order to ensure its sustainability. At the present time, between the pension and OPEB liabilities for state employees and teachers a funding level of $100 million annually is needed to pay the current unfunded liabilities over the next 30 years. Full funding of these liabilities by the state alone is not possible given the magnitude of these obligations due to systemic budget deficits and reliance on short-term federal funding in recent years which make the state’s ability to meet the funding goals very challenging.
In the long run this will mean further increases in state and employee contributions and possibly a reduction in pension benefits. Significantly reducing the health care burden from the pension fund will be essential to ensure sustainability and compliance of the pension with IRS limits. The option of creating a defined contribution plan for some portion may also be necessary at some point, but it would be preferable to improve the sustainability of the existing DB plan, first.
PS: Please note that I administer the City of Rutland Employees Retirement System, in which Rutland Public School (RPS) employees participate. In order to fund the ARC for the RPS portion of the pension, the employer and employee contributions increased and the benefit was decreased to 1 percent (formerly 2 percent) for all service after July 2010. The funded status was improved as a result of these changes, as seen in the Jan 1, 2012 valuation.
Correction: The headline originally and incorrectly stated that the questions were from AARP.
