Story and video: Milne takes aim at Shumlin’s policy, style and record

BARRE — Scott Milne, the Vermont GOP-endorsed gubernatorial candidate, formally launched his campaign Wednesday with a one-two punch aimed at Gov. Peter Shumlin.

Milne promised not to vilify the governor’s character, and then promptly walked into a backhanded attack on Shumlin’s governing strategy.

“Bullying tactics are not respected where I come from,” he said. “Leadership is defined by trust, not brazen displays of power.”

In a flat monotone, Milne described the Shumlin administration as “ultra-progressive,” “radical,” “brazen” and “reckless,” as he took swipes at the governor’s health care, energy and economic policies.

The North Pomfret businessman portrayed himself as a moderate Republican, and he promised to run a low-budget, “contrarian” campaign of ideas that focuses on economic issues affecting the state, including affordable health care, high property tax rates and jobs.

“Our government should not take on unnecessary risks, particularly when we’re spending money we don’t have, raising taxes we can’t afford, creating programs that have no proven likelihood of success, and if you agree with me, we want to end this era of unbridled experimentation with our government,” Milne said in remarks to the media and a crowd of about 80 well-wishers, including fellow Republicans Rep. Tom Koch, Lt. Gov. Phil Scott and Sen. Joe Benning, at the Aldrich Library in Barre.

Republican travel agency executive Scott Milne formally launches his campaign for governor Wednesday, July 23, 2014, at the Aldrich Public Library in Barre. Photo by Anne Galloway/VTDigger

Republican travel agency executive Scott Milne formally launches his campaign for governor Wednesday, July 23, 2014, at the Aldrich Public Library in Barre. Photo by Anne Galloway/VTDigger

Milne said he is compelled to run for governor because “(Shumlin) must answer for his unkept promises and his mistakes.” He accused the Democratic governor of exacerbating the perception that Vermont is unfriendly to business, and he vowed to hold him accountable for the “long-term health of our economy.”

Businesses need and respect government, Milne said, but too much government is an “obstacle to the entrepreneurship and industry that we need in Vermont.”

Shumlin’s “massive overhaul” of the state’s health care system was Milne’s main target. The candidate is concerned about how the state can move Vermont Health Connect forward in a way that’s not “reckless” with people’s money and keep their confidence “that we’re going to have quality health care five to 10 years down the road.”

Milne said he will issue a plan for dealing with the glitch-ridden health care exchange system in September.

Though the candidate has not come out against the governor’s single-payer health care initiative, Milne repeatedly hinted at the riskiness of the plan.

“I promise to offer the voters of Vermont an alternative to the present administration, which has failed by steering the ship of state into unchartered (sic) waters, making promises it cannot fulfill, and I would argue, ignoring the basic needs of Vermonters,” Milne said.

Milne told reporters in an impromptu huddle after the event that he would tackle the state’s education finance system in the first year of the new biennium.

He dodged a question from AP reporter Dave Gram about whether the state should consolidate school boards and/or schools.

“What Vermont should be doing is to have a governor that’s not going to be spending the whole session flying around the country raising special interest money …” Milne said. “The governor should have been rolling up his shirtsleeves and walking to the capitol and working with the House leadership and the Senate leadership to get something on the table.”

Though Milne sang the familiar, pro-business refrain typical of Republican candidates, it is hard to say just how much support Milne actually has in the business community. Big-wigs who tend to show up for campaign events — large numbers of lawmakers, party leaders, conservative lobbyists, Chittenden County and state chamber of commerce leaders — were noticeably absent.

Former statewide GOP candidates like Randy Brock, Vince Illuzzi and Wendy Wilton, key lawmakers such as Heidi Scheuermann, Bill Doyle, Kevin Mullin, Peg Flory and Don Turner, and party stalwarts like Mark Snelling and Susie Hudson did not attend. Perhaps it was no surprise, however, that Thom Lauzon wasn’t around: The Barre mayor has made no secret of his support for Shumlin. He and his wife, Karen, gave the governor $1,000 each last year.

Milne, who has never run for statewide office, has raised a tiny fraction of what he needs to begin to get his message out to Vermonters. He has raised $20,000, while Shumlin has $1.077 million, or roughly 53 times Milne’s cash on hand.

He also is a late entrant to the race. Rep. Heidi Scheuermann, R-Stowe, seriously considered a run for the fifth floor; Bruce Lisman, founder of Campaign for Vermont, pondered a bid as an independent; Brock, the Republican candidate for governor in 2012, eyed another race. All three, in the end, decided against it.

Former Vermont Gov. Jim Douglas introduces Republican travel agency executive Scott Milne as Milne launches his campaign for governor Wednesday, July 23, 2014, at the Aldrich Public Library in Barre. Photo by Anne Galloway/VTDigger

Former Vermont Gov. Jim Douglas introduces Republican travel agency executive Scott Milne as Milne launches his campaign for governor Wednesday, July 23, 2014, at the Aldrich Public Library in Barre. Photo by Anne Galloway/VTDigger

Does he have a chance of winning? Gov. Jim Douglas, who was on hand to introduce Milne as the “next governor of the great state of Vermont,” told reporters that “incumbency is not a guarantee of success.”

Vermonters are looking for a governor who is not part of the system, in his view. Shumlin’s 49 percent favorability rating isn’t very high for someone who is, in theory, in synch with the electorate.

Douglas told the audience that the size of a war chest doesn’t necessarily dictate the outcome of the race.

“I have just two words: Eric Cantor,” he quipped, referring to the Republican majority leader of the U.S. House who recently lost his Virginia primary race.

“Things are changing, and I think Scott’s going to be able to take advantage of that tremendous opportunity,” Douglas said. “It’s a challenging time for our state, we’re struggling to recover from the Great Recession, and facing some headwinds as we do so.”

Douglas, who nearly stole the show, says the state has a high tax burden, an onerous set of regulations and a shrinking workforce. He said 8,500 jobs have disappeared since he left office in 2010.

“A low unemployment rate doesn’t matter much if the numerator and the denominator are both shrinking,” Douglas said.

The former governor also gave an excoriating review of Shumlin’s handling of the health care exchange, which he said was marked by incompetence and confusion, “but they’re going to go for more.”

“They’re going to shift a sixth of our national and state economy into an untested, single-payer, state-run, government-financed scheme,” Douglas said. “We don’t know how it will work; we don’t know how much it will cost; we don’t know how we’re going to fund it. Other than that it sounds like a great idea.”

Douglas said Milne has not been affected by the “stale air of the Statehouse,” and he understands the concerns of the average Vermonter. Most importantly, he will bring balance to state government, in Douglas’ view.

“To be perfectly honest, it wasn’t really good for the state to have my party controlling every office for over a century, and it’s not good for the other party to control all of the offices,” Douglas said. “I think the best ideas are crafted when all sides come together and find common ground.”

There are no Republicans seeking any statewide office below that of lieutenant governor.

Anne Galloway

Leave a Reply

14 Comments on "Story and video: Milne takes aim at Shumlin’s policy, style and record"


Comment Policy requires that all commenters identify themselves by their authentic first and last names. Initials, pseudonyms or screen names are not permissible.

No personal harassment, abuse, or hate speech is permitted. Be succinct and to the point. If your comment is over 500 words, consider sending a commentary instead.

We personally review and moderate every comment that is posted here. This takes a lot of time; please consider donating to keep the conversation productive and informative.

The purpose of this policy is to encourage a civil discourse among readers who are willing to stand behind their identities and their comments. VTDigger has created a safe zone for readers who wish to engage in a thoughtful discussion on a range of subjects. We hope you join the conversation.

Privacy policy
Sort by:   newest | oldest | most voted
Doug Hoffer
2 years 5 months ago

Former Governor Douglas is quoted as saying that “8,500 jobs have disappeared since he left office in 2010.”

Actually, the VT Dept. of Labor reports that we have 7,700 more jobs now than in Dec. of 2010, his last full month in office. [CES, non-farm payroll, seasonally adjusted] And it’s noteworthy that all that job growth has been in the private sector.

As for “employment, which includes self-employment, there are 950 more Vermonters “employed” now then in Dec. 2010. [Vt Dept. of Labor, LAUS, seasonally adjusted]

Mr. Douglas’ assertion is not supported by the facts.

Jim christiansen
2 years 5 months ago

It is pretty clear that the former Governor is talking about total participation in the labor force “numerator and denominator both shrinking” rather than “new” job totals over a fixed 3+ year window.

Doug, do you know if there is data that breaks down the type of job that is being created in VT? Are these good, full-time, support a family with insurance jobs, or are they hospitality, subsidy and 3 squares VT required to live jobs?

It would be great if you could provide that information. Thanks.

Doug Hoffer
2 years 5 months ago

The Governor is reported to have said jobs.

The information you mentioned is available. However, I just got to the office so I can’t do it until tonight or the weekend.

Keith Stern
2 years 5 months ago

Do you have the numbers of the comparison in the healthcare industry and corrections in that time period? Just curious how that affects the numbers.

David Dempsey
2 years 5 months ago

How do you explain the stagnant collection of personal income taxes?

Doug Hoffer
2 years 5 months ago
Walter Carpenter
2 years 5 months ago

“8,500 jobs have disappeared since he left office in 2010.”

Thanks, Doug. Do you know by any chance how many jobs disappeared when Douglas was in office?

Nancy Gardner
2 years 5 months ago
Douglas was governor when Vermont reformed its corporate income tax in 2004. Per the legislature’s Statement of Intent: “Vermont’s separate accounting system is inadequate to measure accurately the income of a corporation with non-Vermont affiliates and creates tax disadvantages for Vermont corporations which compete with multistate and multinational corporations doing business in Vermont.” The tax rate is not the problem. The problem is separate accounting which allows big business to shift profits from one state to another state…or another country. However, Vermont’s 2004 tax reform only solves state to state, subsidiary to subsidiary profit shifting. Contrary to the statement of… Read more »
Paul Donovan
2 years 5 months ago

“ultra-progressive,” “radical,” “brazen”
“reckless,” and “unbridled experimentation with our government”? Could we leave the overheated rhetoric to the folks on the national stage, please?

2 years 5 months ago

Yes Paul, I guess this is what passes as a positive campaign..Brent Burns, Scott Milne’s campaign manager said the following: ” Milne plans to run a positive campaign based on the issues, and he(Milne) won’t be throwing “ hand grenades.” Times Argus –July 11, 2014

Claire broughton
2 years 5 months ago

What are his [ Milne] feelings on this pipeline? Does anyone know?

Ron Pulcer
2 years 5 months ago
I was (and still am) hoping for a more positive tone in this year’s Governor’s race. The last two Gubernatorial races were pretty negative. Even though I support the concept of universal healthcare (single payer or fewer payers, less bureaucracy, sustainable costs), there is lot to criticize Governor Shumlin on, since he did not comply with Act 48’s provision for a financing plan by 2013. Also, the CVPS $21M ratepayer-buyout issue, etc. What Mr. Milne has said about Gov. Shumlin is not “news”. We read VTDigger and we follow what is going on. Please, Mr. Milne, tell us more… Read more »
Walter Carpenter
2 years 5 months ago

” Remember former Governor Jim Douglas’ proposal to privatize the Vermont Lottery, by selling the Vermont Lottery to the former Lehman Bros. ”

Good point, Ron…

Craig Kneeland
2 years 5 months ago

If the numerator and denominator of the unemployment fraction are both shrinking, but the numerator is shrinking more than the denominator, why isn’t that a good thing? We need a governor that can do basic math.

Thanks for reporting an error with the story, "Story and video: Milne takes aim at Shumlin’s policy, style and..."