Details emerge on cost of health care plans under the Vermont Exchange

Robin Lunge

Robin Lunge, director of health care reform for the Shumlin administration, updates the Vermont Health Access Oversight Committee in June on the progress of setting up a health benefits exchange where Vermonters will purchase health insurance. VTD File Photo/Alan Panebaker

The state has released its recommended “cost-sharing” structure for insurance plans offered through the federal health care exchange.

The plan will limit the maximum out-of-pocket costs paid for by an individual and families. The cap is $6,250 for an individual and $12,500 for a family of four. In addition, Vermonters insured in the exchange will be responsible for up to $1,250 in prescription drug costs. The maximum deductible allowed in the exchange is $2,000.

The exchange will go into effect in 2014, and the state plans to use it as a platform for the Shumlin administration’s ambitious single payer health care plan.

Robin Lunge, the director of health care reform under Gov. Peter Shumlin, explained to reporters that the administration is “required to do the exchange, but that’s not where the governor wants to end up.”

Health insurance premiums in the new federal exchange will fluctuate, depending on the quality of the plan and the level of subsidy available for individuals. Premium levels have not yet been developed for the nine different plans that will be offered through the exchange.

“We live in a federal system where the first step is building the exchange,” Lunge said. “The exchange requires a range of plan designs at actuarial levels. We’re trying to balance the diverse needs of consumers by having a range of choices from what some feel is inadequate to what some people think is too rich.”

Monthly premiums for an individual would represent no more than 9.5 percent of total income, according to a sample sliding scale spreadsheet from the Department of Vermont Health Access that is based on a “silver” level plan. Vermonters whose income is 400 percent of poverty or lower will qualify for a federal tax credit.

For an individual who makes $2,793 per month, the monthly premium for a silver plan would be $189, with the federal subsidy. The rate for individuals who make $3,724 a month is $354. A family of four living on $3,842 a month would pay $242 a month and household incomes of as much as $7,684 would pay $730 a month.

The total cost of the benefits offered in the exchange will be split between insurers and consumers. There are four actuarial levels in the plan, and each one is meant to clarify the value of the insurance, based on what percentage of the health care costs incurred by patients is covered by the insurer. The actuarial values are grouped by “metal level.” The bronze plan, for example, covers 60 percent of the cost of a patient’s health care; silver covers 70 percent; gold covers 80 percent; and platinum covers 90 percent.

Catamount Health, the state subsidized program for uninsured Vermonters, falls somewhere between gold and platinum, according to Lunge.

The Shumlin administration has set up six different “specified plan designs” within each “metal level” and three “choice designs” that allow insurance companies to develop alternative plans for consumers. The details of each plan vary, depending on the co-pay and coinsurance amounts for specific services.

The specified platinum plan, for example has a $250 deductible and an out-of-pocket maximum of $1,250 for medical care and $1,250 for prescription drugs. Office visits include a $10 copay, and a trip to the ER is $100.

Under the sample “choice” bronze plan, the medical deductible is $2,000 and the prescription drug deductible is $1,250. The total out-of-pocket costs are $6,250 for medical care and $1,250 for drugs. The cost of the extras — ambulance services, specialists, radiology, etc. — is shared 50/50 by patients and insurers.

Lunge presented her recommendations to the Green Mountain Care Board on Tuesday. The board will make a decision about whether to adopt the plan in late September after a public comment period of six weeks.

Two weeks ago, Lunge asked the board to consider a model plan for the scope of “essential health benefits” in the exchange. BlueCross BlueShield of Vermont was selected as the “benchmark” insurance plan for the exchange. Vermont’s two other health insurers, MVP and CIGNA, will be required to emulate the BlueCross plan.

Anne Galloway

Leave a Reply

16 Comments on "Details emerge on cost of health care plans under the Vermont Exchange"


Comment Policy requires that all commenters identify themselves by their authentic first and last names. Initials, pseudonyms or screen names are not permissible.

No personal harassment, abuse, or hate speech is permitted. Be succinct and to the point. If your comment is over 500 words, consider sending a commentary instead.

We personally review and moderate every comment that is posted here. This takes a lot of time; please consider donating to keep the conversation productive and informative.

The purpose of this policy is to encourage a civil discourse among readers who are willing to stand behind their identities and their comments. VTDigger has created a safe zone for readers who wish to engage in a thoughtful discussion on a range of subjects. We hope you join the conversation.

Privacy policy
Sort by:   newest | oldest | most voted
Len Vignola
4 years 4 months ago

My wife & I are in our mid-70’s. We are covered by Medicare A&B. Our premiums are deducted from mo. social security payments. We also have VT Blue65 to supplement Medicare coverage. We have Blue Medicare Rx coverage for prescriptions. We pay the mo. premiums for both to BC. These plans have been working very well for us & are reasonably affordable.
Can someone please tell me if we can. My wife has been a diabetic for 51 yrs.- this is an URGENT REQUEST!
Thank you.

Dan McCauliffe
4 years 4 months ago

Mr. Vignola,

The health care exchange is a temporary place to buy health insurance starting in 2014. Vermont will discard the exchange on or before 2017 when the plan is to move to a single payer health care system. You will be interested to learn that the Shumlin administration is seeking a waiver so that Medicare and Medicaid patients can be rolled into the single payer system with most other Vermonters. What this means to you and your wife and other Medicare patients is uncertain, as the details of the single payer plan are still largely unknown.

Dave Bellini
4 years 4 months ago

“EHB approach to be reviewed by the federal government in 2016
–leaves open the possibility of an exponential increase in state costs in 2016”

From the GMCB website August 9, powerpoint summary.

So can anyone tell me the plan when the FEDS pull the plug on funding in 2016? How much will folks pay after the “exponential increase in state costs”?

Tom Licata
4 years 4 months ago
Anne Galloway writes: “The program is for people who have no insurance.” This is a false statement. Less than 10% of Vermonters lack insurance and the state of Vermont wouldn’t be going to all this trouble for such a small population-set. Anne’s cheerleading belies Vermont Digger’s biases. The state of Vermont’s collectivism will deliver impoverishment and misery to its people. Churchill said it best: “Socialism is a philosophy of failure, the creed of ignorance, and the gospel of envy, its inherent virtue is the equal sharing of misery.” Anne, as you know, you find comfort in your media brethren (WCAX,… Read more »
Bob Johnson
4 years 4 months ago

And yet the countries with the highest standards of healthcare, best infrastructure, best education and longest life expectancies are… wait for it… ultra-socialist!

Does getting everything wrong ever make you stop and question your assumptions?

Or to you just keep drooling at the thought of a coming apocalypse that never seems to get here?

David Bell
4 years 4 months ago

” Less than 10% of Vermonters lack insurance and the state of Vermont wouldn’t be going to all this trouble for such a small population-set.”

I’m sure the idea of compassion is utterly foreign to you, and so the notion of going to some trouble for those in need is beyond your grasp.

Thankfully, the same is not true of the Vermont state government.

Tom Licata
4 years 4 months ago

“They who can give up essential liberty to obtain a little temporary safety, deserve neither liberty nor safety.” – Benjamin Franklin

David Bell
4 years 4 months ago

Yes, the liberty to welsh on paying medical bills, driving up the cost for the rest of us is truly a freedom worth dying for.

Almost as much as the freedom to watch the poor die of treatable illnesses.

Jeanne Keller
4 years 4 months ago
Some facts, folks: 1. The Exchange is not just for the uninsured. The Exchange plans will be available to any individual wanting insurance who is not already covered by a government plan like Medicare or Medicaid. Exchange plans will be available for small businesses (defined as having 50 or fewer employees). So, because Catamount Health will be eliminated in 2014, everyone now on Catamount can go to the Exchange. Anyone now buying individual insurance can go to the Exchange. Small businesses now purchasing through the Chamber, BRS or other associations, can buy through the Exchange if they want to continue… Read more »
Dan McCauliffe
4 years 4 months ago
Jeanne, I agree with your statement: “However, if you do want to buy insurance and you are an individual or small group, the Exchange will be the only place where you can buy insurance. That was decided by the VT Legislature.” In other words, individuals and small businesses with 50 or fewer employees that want to purchase health insurance are not allowed the option to purchase it outside of the exchange, as permitted by the ObamaCare law that established the exchanges. Instead they are forced to purchase it in the exchange, where for many the cost will be substantially higher… Read more »
Robert Lewis
4 years 4 months ago

Why do these “fixes” sound like more layers of the same dysfunctional and confusing crap that we already have?

walter carpenter
4 years 4 months ago
“Instead they are forced to purchase it in the exchange, where for many the cost will be substantially higher than it would have been, had they been allowed to purchase health care outside of the exchange.” I am not sure for who the cost would be higher, except those on Catamount or Vhap, which are regulated by income eligibility. An individual policy for someone who wants to buy health insurance on their own now is about $400 a month premiums with a $5,000 deductible, or about ten grand a year before one can even use the insurance. At least within… Read more »
Karen McCauliffe
4 years 4 months ago
Walter, the coverage is much higher for some businesses that previously purchased their insurance through associations and now are forced into the exchange to continue covering their employees and insuring themselves. The premiums will go up for them over 18%. The Grocers Group thought that their premiums would go up over 40%. Vermont was ranked 48th (best to worst) in the 2011 Small Business Survival Index (released Nov 2011). We will be off the charts for small business survival index in this state!!! Interesting to note, neighboring NH has a rating of 33rd. Plus everyone does not have subsidies in… Read more »
Thanks for reporting an error with the story, "Details emerge on cost of health care plans under the Vermont Exchang..."