Experts: Legal pot in Vermont would conflict with federal law

Marijuana Legaliztion

Vermont state Sen. Peg Flory, Attorney Mary Beth Buchanan and Vermont ACLU policy director Chloé White talk about challenges posed to marijuana legalization by potential conflicts between state and federal law.

Lawmakers discussing legalizing marijuana in Vermont have not taken into account the drug’s prohibition at the federal level, a state senator said Wednesday.

Sen. Peg Flory, R-Rutland, spoke on a panel that discussed conflicts between state and federal marijuana laws. The panel was hosted by the Vermont chapter of the Federalist Society, a conservative membership organization that supports limited government.

The event, open to the public, was largely geared toward lawyers. Thomas Little, who represented Shelburne in the Vermont House from 1992 to 2002, moderated the discussion.

Earlier this year, the Legislature approved a bill — ultimately vetoed by Gov. Phil Scott — that would have allowed Vermont adults to possess small quantities of pot and to grow a limited number of plants.

Attorney Mary Beth Buchanan, a former federal prosecutor, said that, despite the spreading legalization of medical and recreational marijuana at the state level, its use is still prohibited by federal law.

Buchanan said when state and federal laws conflict, the Constitution’s “Supremacy Clause” gives priority to the federal law.

Despite that, Buchanan said that 29 states have legalized medical marijuana and eight have legalized its recreational use. In Vermont, medical marijuana use has been legal since 2011.

Under the Obama administration, the Department of Justice declined to interfere with states’ legalization efforts.

VTDigger is underwritten by:

Jonathan Adler, a law professor at Case Western Reserve University, said that even if the federal government wanted to crack down, it would have a hard time doing so. Adler said that as a practical matter, the feds simply don’t have the resources.

He pointed to the case of Colorado and Washington, the first two states to legalize recreational marijuana. Worldwide, the DEA “has less than one quarter of the officers as there are state and local law enforcement in Colorado and Washington,” Adler said, and so they “can’t go around rounding up people for growing marijuana at their house.”

But, Adler said, there are a host of other problems besides federal raids that states legalizing marijuana need to consider. Adler said banks and other financial institutions usually want to stay as far away as possible from backing the commercial production, transportation, or sale of marijuana.

That makes it hard for companies involved in marijuana, regardless of what state they operate in, to get loans or insurance. Adler said there’s also a question of whether lawyers, accountants, and other professionals bound by codes of conduct should offer their services to such companies.

“Can a lawyer, for example, draw up papers for a client to create an LLC that’s going to be a marijuana dispensary?” Adler asked. “That’s still illegal under federal law, and under the code of professional responsibility in every state, you cannot counsel a client about how to engage in an activity that will involve a violation of law.”

Peg Flory

Sen. Peg Flory, R-Rutland. Photo by Elizabeth Hewitt/VTDigger

Flory, an attorney, said that some of the problems Adler mentioned have been sticking points in Vermont’s legalization efforts.

Flory said Vermont lawmakers didn’t fully think out all the ways federal prohibition would affect dispensaries and citizens when the state legalized medical marijuana.

For instance, Flory said the Legislature anticipated medical marijuana dispensaries would be able to have nonprofit tax status, but “that didn’t happen.”

“There’s no nonprofit in their right mind that is is going to try to get the federal tax benefits for having something that’s federally against the law,” Flory said. “It just didn’t click with us — the bind we were putting them through when you’ve got the tension between state law being this and federal law being exactly the opposite.”

Drug testing for commercial driver’s licenses is also governed by federal law, Flory said, as is financing for many personal and business loans.

“What happens if you have a Farmers Home (Administration) loan or a G.I. federally funded loan?” Flory asked. “If the feds decide to enforce (the prohibition of marijuana), can they come in and call in your mortgage?”

Flory said the deep interconnections Vermont and its citizens have with federal laws and programs means that “this whole issue is unresolved because you don’t know what the feds are going to do.”

Chloé White, policy director of the Vermont ACLU, said she recognized the concerns about state-federal conflict.

Still, she said “the ACLU as a whole, nationally, is for decriminalization and ultimately legalization of marijuana.”

VTDigger is underwritten by:

White said beginning criminal justice reform at the state level is essential.

“When it comes to marijuana,” she added, “we see that other states have implemented legalization and taxation and regulation successfully and there hasn’t been — of course we have a new administration — an enormous crackdown.”

White said she thinks states can serve as “bastions of innovation.”

After the panel discussion ended, Little said he thinks the biggest challenge of legalizing marijuana in Vermont is identifying unintended consequences, including conflicts with federal laws.

Missing out on the latest scoop? Sign up here to get a weekly email with all of VTDigger's reporting on politics. And in case you can't get enough of the Statehouse, sign up for Final Reading for a rundown on the day's news in the Legislature.


Cyrus Ready-Campbell

About Cyrus

Cyrus Ready-Campbell is a reporting intern for VTDigger. He graduated from Stanford University in 2017, where he wrote for the Stanford Daily and studied history, computer science and creative writing. In 2015 he wrote for the Half Moon Bay Review in Half Moon Bay, California, as a Rebele journalism intern. He is originally from West Bolton and now lives in St. Johnsbury.

Email: [email protected]

Reader Footnotes

VTDigger will no longer be publishing Reader Footnotes. We welcome your feedback on this decision; please write to [email protected]. Readers who have a substantive opinion may submit a commentary. See our guidelines. We also encourage readers to use our 'Tip Drop' and 'Report an Error' forms found at the end of every article.


Recent Stories

Thanks for reporting an error with the story, "Experts: Legal pot in Vermont would conflict with federal law"