[V]ERNON — Voters on Tuesday approved pulling out of the regional Brattleboro Union High School District, a move that allows Vernon to try to preserve its unique choice options for middle- and high-schoolers.
Residents opted to withdraw from what’s known as BUHS District No. 6 by a tally of 374 in favor and 124 against, according to the town clerk.
Vernon’s vote is not the final say on the matter. The four other towns in the union — Brattleboro, Dummerston, Guilford and Putney — must vote in November on whether Vernon can exit the union, and the state would also need to sign off on the move.
“I am pleased to have the continued support for our school by the residents of Vernon,” School Board Chairman Mike Hebert said. “Now the board has a great deal of work to do in order to move forward with a comprehensive education plan which will have the best interests of our students, staff and taxpayers at its core.”
“We are looking forward to a continued positive relationship with our neighboring towns as they move forward with their Act 46 activities,” Hebert added.
Tuesday’s vote was spurred by continuing debate about how Vernon fits into any proposed school district merger under Act 46, the 2015 state law that pushes for larger, consolidated districts throughout Vermont.
Windham Southeast Supervisory Union officials spent months studying a proposed merger of all the union’s school districts. But Vernon’s representatives walked away from that study earlier this year, citing concerns about the merger process and the town’s school choice setup.
Vernon operates its own elementary school. Starting in seventh grade, Vernon students can be tuitioned to schools other than Brattleboro, with a popular alternative destination being Pioneer Valley in Massachusetts.
A merger with the other Windham Southeast districts, which do not allow such options, would jeopardize Vernon’s school choice. State education officials have said merging districts must have or adopt the same structure when it comes to the grades for which they operate schools or tuition students.
So that left Vernon and the other Windham Southeast districts at an impasse, given that they are legally bound together in the BUHS District.
Leaving the district would resolve that impasse. Vernon officials could seek an Act 46 option that preserves its school choice, while representatives of the other school districts would be free to study a merger among themselves.
If Vernon is allowed to depart the district, the town’s students still would be able to attend Brattleboro Area Middle School and Brattleboro Union High School via a tuition arrangement. Most Vernon students currently choose Brattleboro, and officials have said they don’t envision that changing.
Officials also have said they don’t expect any significant financial detriment to either the Vernon School District or the remaining union members if Vernon leaves BUHS. The idea is that Vernon would contract with the larger, unified district in the Brattleboro area for services such as special education and professional development.
But Vernon also would have to try to convince state officials that the school district can maintain independent governance and still meet the requirements of Act 46. “We want to form an independent, alternative district,” Hebert said in a June interview.
