Moral Economy
VTDigger Photo by Kevin O’Connor

[T]he first proposition came when Vermont Interfaith Action โ€” a grassroots coalition of several dozen Green Mountain religious congregations โ€” was seeking a way to help people squeezed by income inequality: Why not urge state leaders to tally up a budget that, for debateโ€™s sake, reveals the real cost of all needed public services, rather than just start annual negotiations with an already pared-down plan?

Now introducing that idea at churches and synagogues through a โ€œBuilding Vermontโ€™s Moral Economyโ€ campaign, the group is facing other questions. Take the Brattleboro parishioner who raised his hand to say he moved cross-country from Los Angeles, where residents convinced the nationโ€™s largest local government to increase the minimum wage to $15.

Why, the man asked, wasnโ€™t the Vermont effort thinking equally big?

โ€œPeople are hungry for even more action,โ€ repliesย the Rev. Debbie Ingram, the groupโ€™s executive director. โ€œWe try to address root causes and make change systemically. This is just a manageable first step.โ€

To take another, 30 representatives of spiritual and social justice organizations gathered this past Saturday for a โ€œSummit on a Moral Economyโ€ to strategize how to achieve their public policy goals.

โ€œWe know there are a lot of others who share our view that we need an economy that works for all Vermonters,โ€ Ingram says. โ€œWeโ€™re trying to bring together allies so we can understand what each other is doing and work collaboratively.โ€

But participants at the summit, co-sponsored by the Vermont Workersโ€™ Center at Essex Junctionโ€™s Holy Family Catholic Church, found it wasnโ€™t easy to settle on one solution.

โ€œWe had a very lively discussion about the enormity of the problem,โ€ Ingram says, โ€œand we realized we have to come at it from many different angles โ€” from how workers are treated to government programs to how we invest more in the state for better paying jobs.โ€

Vermont Interfaith Action began its efforts last month by teaming with the Public Assets Institute, a nonprofit, nonpartisan Montpelier-based think tank, for a summer and fall statewide tour to explain how stagnant wages and cuts in state services are challenging more and more residents.

The percentage of children living below the poverty level, for example, hit 15.3 percent this past year โ€” a rate topped only in 2010 during the depths of the last recession.

โ€œWe believe income inequality is the biggest problem Vermont faces today,โ€ Paul Cillo, the instituteโ€™s founder, said during the tourโ€™s first stops in Brattleboro, Burlington, East Arlington, Montpelier, White River Junction and, just last Friday, Danville and Middlebury.

The โ€œBuilding Vermontโ€™s Moral Economyโ€ campaign is hoping to convince people to ask their legislators and other state leaders to report how much it would cost to pay for all needed services โ€” not necessarily so that budget would be approved, but as a means to demonstrate the extent of the demand and to spark discussion on what should be done.

โ€œOur clergy were the impetus for focusing on this as an issue,โ€ Ingram says. โ€œThey were reflecting together on how many people come to their doors for charitable help, and the need is greater than the resources. They started saying, โ€˜Why is this? Whatโ€™s wrong with our system?โ€™โ€

โ€œWe realize when we decided to make this the first step that it is a bit technical and maybe seems policy-wonkish,โ€ she continues. โ€œBut people understand what weโ€™re talking about is a baseline of honest information so we can have a good, vital public debate.โ€

The group is set to elaborate at several more public meetings, including Oct. 25 at 1 p.m. at Rutlandโ€™s Grace Congregational United Church of Christ and Nov. 1 at 2 p.m. at Springfieldโ€™s First Congregational Church.

โ€œOne of the things I love about Vermont is people really want to take the bulls by the horns and move quickly, yet most understand we have to work one step at a time,โ€ Ingram says. โ€œSometimes change has to be incremental โ€” but we do intend to have more action.โ€

Kevin Oโ€™Connor, a former staffer of the Rutland Herald and Barre-Montpelier Times Argus, is a Brattleboro-based writer. Email: kevinoconnorvt@gmail.comย 

VTDigger's southern Vermont and features reporter.

8 replies on “Churches find ‘Building Moral Economy’ a challenge”