Business & Economy

Independent contractors seek clearer employment status

A new statutory definition of “independent contractor” is in the works — again.

The effort is driven in part by Vermont’s burgeoning creative economy, including game designers, computer programmers and website developers, according to Secretary of Commerce Lawrence Miller.

Secretary of Commerce & Community Development Lawrence Miller. File photo by Hilary Niles/VTDigger

Secretary of Commerce & Community Development Lawrence Miller. File photo by Hilary Niles/VTDigger

If a new definition is created with S.220, it may also lead to an online registry to verify freelancers’ status as independent contractors recognized by the state.

At stake for employers is the cost of unemployment and workers’ compensation insurance they have to pay for workers who are considered employees. On the flip side of that equation, unemployment and workers’ compensation benefits are at stake for workers.

A third facet, Miller says, are the contracts that some freelancers are losing to out-of-state competition.

Vermont companies often avoid hiring in-state freelancers because they’re afraid of getting caught in unemployment insurance or workers’ compensation audits, Labor Commissioner Annie Noonan told the Senate Committee on Economic Development, Housing & General Affairs Wednesday morning.

Miller explained in December that the issue mostly affects the information technology sector.

“In the emerging marketplace for intellectual property development, there are a lot of people making a living as freelancers,” Miller said. “If (a company) hires somebody to do some coding, on a project, from their home, are they an employee or an independent contractor?”

Miller said state law currently provides multiple tests to distinguish between employees and independent contractors, leading to ambiguity that companies would rather avoid by hiring out of state.

Because the solution is a statutory redefinition of “independent contractor,” however, other fields will be affected along with IT. The debate from 2013 over whether or not newspaper carriers are employees is “bound up” in this issue, Miller said.

“You don’t want to erode protections, especially around safety and abuse of workers,” Miller said. But the world has changed, he said, and relevant statutes need to reflect that transformation.

Noonan reassured lawmakers that compliance with unemployment and workers’ compensation laws is only required of companies who hire independent contractors. A homeowner who hires someone to build a deck, for example, would not be expected to insure that individual.

Existing law also provides an exclusion for the directors of corporations or limited liability companies. Up to four directors can opt out of unemployment and workers’ compensation protections, though employees of such a company would still need to be covered.

The new definition being drafted is of particular interest to Noonan, who shepherded similar legislation through the House in 2012, only to see H.762  buckle in the Senate under the weight of different labor issues.

Labor Commissioner Annie Noonan. File photo by Hilary Niles/VTDigger

Labor Commissioner Annie Noonan. File photo by Hilary Niles/VTDigger

She’s on board with the clarity helping independent contractors compete for jobs. And she wants to be sure that protective provisions don’t get watered down.

Noonan told the committee about cracking down on a restaurant recently when her department learned management was claiming its entire wait staff were independent contractors.

“It’s a form of wage fraud,” Noonan said.

She said her goal is to ensure that employers pay appropriate taxes, while not forcing genuine independent contractors into an uncompetitive situation.

The draft language is one part of a larger jobs bill being developed by the committee.

Want to stay on top of the latest business news? Sign up here to get a weekly email on all of VTDigger's reporting on local companies and economic trends. And check out our new Business section here.


Hilary Niles

About Hilary

Hilary Niles joined VTDigger in June 2013 as data specialist and business reporter. She returns to New England from the Missouri School of Journalism in Columbia, where she completed her master's coursework. While there, she worked at Investigative Reporters & Editors and covered state and local government for radio, print and the Web. She’s been a researcher-in-residence at American University’s Investigative Reporting Workshop in Washington, D.C.; a reporter and community radio program director in the New Hampshire; and, in Boston, a public radio producer. She studied English at the University of New Hampshire and documentary writing at the Salt Institute for Documentary Studies in Maine.

Email: [email protected]

Follow Hilary on Twitter @nilesmedia

Send us your thoughts

VTDigger is now accepting letters to the editor. For information about our guidelines, and access to the letter form, please click here.


Recent Stories

Thanks for reporting an error with the story, "Independent contractors seek clearer employment status"