WCAX/WDEV Poll: Shumlin has high approval rating, holds sure lead over Republican challenger

Governor Peter Shumlin spoke about H. 413 to residents of The Lodge and The Shores at Shelburne Bay. VTD Photo/Taylor Dobbs

Governor Peter Shumlin spoke about H. 413 to residents of The Lodge and The Shores at Shelburne Bay. VTD Photo/Taylor Dobbs

Democratic Gov. Peter Shumlin would win 60 percent of the vote if the gubernatorial election were held today, according to a poll paid for by WCAX, WDEV and the Vermont Business Magazine.

About 27 percent of the more than 600 survey respondents gave their support to Republican Sen. Randy Brock.

The poll, conducted by Castleton Polling Institute, also showed President Barack Obama would win over Republican contender Mitt Romney by a similar margin (59.3 percent to 27.5 percent); Lt. Gov. Phil Scott has a 56.5 percent approval rating; and the Legislature’s approval rating was 57.5 percent. Lawmakers also had high negatives: 31.5 percent disapproved of legislators’ performance in the 2012 session.

At 65 percent, Shumlin’s overall approval rating has outstripped former Republican Gov. Jim Douglas’ favorability ratings, according to Eric Davis, a frequent pundit and retired Middlebury College professor.

Vermont governors tend to have high approval ratings, especially at the beginning of their tenures in office. “It didn’t surprise me Shumlin had over 60 percent,” Davis said. “That’s consistent with first-term governors in the past, such as Douglas and Dean.”

Brock’s media consultant, Robert Wickers, issued a statement downplaying the significance of the poll and attributed Shumlin’s good showing to high name recognition.

“What the poll does not show is the concern voters have about his failed record on jobs, the economy, health care, and energy,” Wickers wrote. “These poll numbers are similar to the poll numbers at the start of Randy Brock’s 2004 campaign for State Auditor, which he went on to win by 10 points.  The campaign for governor has just begun.  As Vermonters learn more about Randy, and hear his positive message of economic growth and prosperity, this race will tighten.”

Davis agrees that name recognition is the name of the game this early in the race.

“I wasn’t surprised Shumlin had a big lead,” Davis said. “Early polls are about name recognition more than anything else. Randy Brock had low name recognition last year and my guess is that he is as low as he was in the (WCAX/WDEV/VBM) poll because his name recognition was low. He’s started to run bio ads on TV and that may help him.”

Those ads, however, may no longer be as effective as they once were, Davis said. More voters, in his view, are gravitating to the Web for information instead of relying on broadcast and print news sources. He speculates that candidates may invest more money in Web advertising this campaign season.

Correction: Vermont Business Magazine shared the cost of the poll with WCAX and WDEV. All three organizations were involved in the development of the questions. Story corrected on May 24 at 9:30 a.m.


Anne Galloway

Comment Policy

VTDigger.org requires that all commenters identify themselves by their authentic first and last names. Initials, pseudonyms or screen names are not permissible.

No personal harrassment, abuse, or hate speech is permitted. Be succinct and to the point. Comments should be 1000 characters or fewer. If your comment is over 500 words, consider sending a commentary instead.

We personally review and moderate every comment that is posted here. This takes a lot of time; please consider donating to keep the conversation productive and informative.

The purpose of this policy is to encourage a civil discourse among readers who are willing to stand behind their identities and their comments. VTDigger has created a safe zone for readers who wish to engage in a thoughtful discussion on a range of subjects. We hope you join the conversation. If you have questions or concerns about our commenting platform, please review our Commenting FAQ.

Privacy policy
  • How long are the Governor’s coat tails?

    Jim Condos should be re-elected based on his record of service alone, but will the coat-tail effect influence anyone’s interested in running against him? IS anyone running against him?

  • Ellen Oxfeld

    Another person who should be elected is Beth Pearce, who was appointed by Governor Shumlin to the State Treasurer’s job after Jeb Spaulding joined the administration. Her race is really important because she has done a good job and her challenger — Wendy Wilton — is using the election to spread misleading information about the future implementation of a single payer health care system in Vermont.

    Wilton’s numbers are not accurate, but she will try to scare people with them. The fact is that every major study that the state has commissioned has always come to the same basic conclusion — single payer is the most efficient way to pay for health care and also is the only way we can cover all Vermonters.

  • walter carpenter

    Has Beth Pearce declared her candidacy yet?

  • Stan Hopson

    Most non political Vermonters I know are frightened about the prospect of single payer. Wilton has tremendous credibility as a treasurer and isn’t sticking her head in the Administation sandbox unlike Beth Pierce. Frankly as an independent, I’d rather have Wilton keeping an eye on GMC then the rubber-stamp currently in place.

  • Eddie Fisher

    Everyone knows the incumbant always holds a lead ,at first ! It has been interesting to watch the evolution of political change in WCAX and basicly all Vermont medias opinions over the last few years. Shumlin , Welch, Leahy ? Please !…..TRI…. Total Rhetoric Incorporated!

Thanks for reporting an error with the story, "WCAX/WDEV Poll: Shumlin has high approval rating, holds sure lead ove..."