Vermonters lead the charge in tar sands protests

Bill McKibben. Photo courtesy of Bill McKibben
Bill McKibben. Photo courtesy of Bill McKibben

The ‘sit-in’ protests in Washington D.C. resulting in the arrest of environmentalist author William McKibben, Vermont Law School professor Gus Speth and roughly 150 others, are scheduled to continue every day from now until Sept. 3. About 30 more Vermonters have banded together and are slated to go down Sunday.

McKibben, author of the seminal book about climate change, End of Nature, is also the founder of the activist group Tar Sands Action, and Speth, a Vermont Law School environmental lawyer and activist, were arrested and held over the weekend for protesting against a permit for a $7 billion pipeline that would run from Alberta Canada to the eastern part of Texas. They were released Monday afternoon.

Because the pipeline crosses international boundaries, it was originally up to the State Department to decide whether to approve the project, but due to disagreements between the Environmental Protection Agency and the State Department, President Obama is the one who signs or rejects the permit. Activists are participating in the sit-in to let the president know he should reject the permit, and people are coming from all corners of the country to join. Climate scientist and director of NASA’s Goddard Institute James Hansen described the tar sands oil extraction development as a game-over proposition for climate change in an interview with the Huffington Post Sunday.

After the first round of arrests, authorities held roughly 65 protesters much longer than expected. According to Kathryn Blume, an organizer of 350 Vermont– an environmental activist group – the usual penalty for civil disobedience is a $100 fine and you can be on your way; this was not the case for McKibben and Speth.

“They held McKibben and others over the weekend because they wanted to do it as a deterrent to prevent other people to come,” Blume said.

Blume and others are not dissuaded. Protests happened in similar manners both Sunday and Monday,  resulting in roughly 100 people arrested since the original 65 on Saturday, and Blume is heading down with at least 25 to 30 Vermonters on Sunday to have sit-in on Tuesday.

Blume said they have arranged for a bus, which still has open seats, to travel down to Washington on Sunday. The protesters will have civil disobedience training on Monday to go over how the process works.

“I don’t know exactly what the training will be, but I suspect they are going to go over the procedure of being arrested,” Blume said. “Even though it’s a cause you believe in, getting arrested is outside most peoples’ comfort zone.”

The participants will then go to the White House on Tuesday and position themselves in a place to be considered trespassing. According to Blume, the police will then come and give three warnings, at the end of which the protesters will be arrested. Blume said most people will pay the $100 fine so they can get back to their regular lives;  the bus will return Wednesday evening.

Activists have been readying to have the sit-in for some time as a letter inviting all to come to participate was sent in the end of June. The beginning of the letter states:  “The short version (of this letter) is we want you to consider doing something hard: coming to Washington in the hottest and stickiest weeks of the summer and engaging in civil disobedience that will quite possibly get you arrested.”

[youtube o5QqsLsMroM]

Many of the people who sent out the invitation also sent a letter  to the president asking him to reject the permit on Aug.  3. The environmental activists wrote: “The tar sands are a huge pool of carbon, but one that does not make sense to exploit. It takes a lot of energy to extract and refine this resource into usable fuel, and the mining is environmentally destructive.”

Joe Solomon, another organizer of 350,  wrote the following in an email:

“I’ve been thinking a lot about why Vermonters are making this trip, and keep coming back to this thought: It’s fair to say the Keystone XL is currently the greatest threat to Vermont’s climate future. We can debate how much oil the pipeline will spill onto America’s heartland, but we can guarantee it will spill a massive amount of carbon into the atmosphere. And all that extra carbon will affect us: hotter summers, worse floods, out-of-whack farms, shrinking ski seasons, and on and on with the growing effects of climate change. So, we’re going down to join Nebraskans and Native Americans and stand with the heartland, but just as much to protect the future for all of us here in the Green Mountain State.”

The pipeline is owned by TransCanada Corp..  Although there has been no construction,  the pipeline is to pump raw oil — extracted from tar sand fields out of Alberta — all the way to Texas. Although the oil companies have cited studies showing tar-sand oil is no more corrosive than regular oil, environmentalists claim the tar sand is much cruder.

According to Josh Fox, Oscar-nominated director of the film Gasland, the biggest industrial development project ever is happening in the tar-sand fields of Alberta and is the size of Florida. In a short film made about the project, Fox said it is the biggest capital investment and largest energy project in the world. He also said the tar sands produce 36 million tons of carbon dioxide a day and is the cause of as much green house gases a day as 1.3 million cars.

“Oil companies have invested $120 billion in tar sands development,” Fox said in his film.

TransCanada has pressed for Obama to sign the permit as it offers approximately 20,000 new jobs for the economy. The president has until Oct. 1, to sign or reject the permit,  and Blume said the decision will be colossal.

“This is an opportunity and a profound decision and will have a monumental change on the future,” Blume said. “A woman turned to her daughter while a group was being arrested (at the protest) and said ‘this is what democracy looks like.’”

Released from prison

According to a Twitter tweet from TarSandsAction, the protesters jailed Saturday and held through the weekend were released at roughly 4 p.m. Monday. Upon release, McKibben was quoted saying:  “I’m so glad more people are getting arrested. We aren’t deterred.”

While in prison, both McKibben and Speth released statements – Speth wrote the following statement through his wife:

“We the prisoners being held in the Central Cell Block of the D.C. Jail need company and encourage the continuation of the protests against the tar sands pipeline. Help us stop this disastrous proposal! I’ve held numerous positions and public office in Washington but my current position feels like one of the most important.” – Gus Speth

McKibben sent the following through the Tar Sand Action legal team:

“Hello everyone! We don’t need sympathy, we need company. It’s clear to us that police were hoping to deter this action, and it’s equally clear to us the opposite will be the result. I’m looking forward to seeing everybody over the next 2 weeks. It has been a little hot here in central cell block, but not as hot as it will be if we don’t stop this project. People here have been in good spirits, and there has been a great deal of learning. We are thinking ahead to this weekend to share stories about Dr King and freedom movement. Even though uncomfortable, this experience has given us a greater sense of that part of history. Come on in, the water is fine.”

If you read us, please support us.

Comment Policy

VTDigger.org requires that all commenters identify themselves by their authentic first and last names. Initials, pseudonyms or screen names are not permissible.

No personal harrassment, abuse, or hate speech is permitted. Comments should be 1000 characters or fewer.

We moderate every comment. Please go to our FAQ for the full policy.

Privacy policy
Eli Sherman

Recent Stories

  • Alex Barnham

    WOW!!! This is knocking on the door of a planetary coffin. If our greatest minds have come up with such a destructive and hazardous plan to supply us with liquid fuel, we need to seriously educate the consumers who are blindly continue doing whatever they want. We cannot just shut off the pipeline, we need to applaud the discontinuation of the moronic activities that demand useless consumption. Make serious efforts to shut down the “addictive entertainment” that leads to the demand for liquid fuel. I still hear race cars roaring around in circles going nowhere, still see people driving 70-80 mph with the AC going full blast, I still smell the crap coming out of cars and trucks that refuse to drive sensibly. Is it too late to stop this insane merry-go-round? This insanity will eventually lead to a nuclear war that will stop everything we are stupidly demanding.

  • Increased energy efficiency is much better than tar sand oil.

    Energy efficiency projects:

    – will make the US more competitive, increase exports and reduce the trade balance.

    – usually have simple payback periods of 6 months to 5 years. 

    – reduce the need for expensive and highly visible transmission and distribution systems.

    – reduce two to five times the energy consumption and greenhouse gas emissions and create two to three times more jobs than renewables per dollar invested; no studies, research, demonstration and pilot plants will be required. 

    – have minimal or no pollution, are invisible and quiet, are peaceful; no opposition groups demonstrating against them, something people really like.

    – are by far the cleanest energy development anyone can engage in; they often are quick, cheap and easy.

    – have a capacity factor = 1.0 and are available 24/7/365.

    – use materials, such as for taping, sealing, caulking, insulation, windows, doors, refrigerators, water heaters, furnaces, fans, air conditioners, etc., that are almost entirely made in the US. They represent about 30% of a project cost, the rest is mostly labor. About 70% of the materials cost of expensive renewables, such as PV solar, is imported (panels from China, inverters from Germany), the rest of the materials cost is miscellaneous electrical items and brackets.

    – will quickly reduce CO2 at the lowest cost per dollar invested AND make the economy more efficient in many areas which will raise living standards, or prevent them from falling further. 

    – if done before renewables, will reduce the future capacities and capital costs of renewables. 

  • Al Salzman

    Cheers to Vermonter Bill McKibben and his friends in protesting the preposterous oil sands pipeline! We need the same ‘on the streets’ commitment to stop the war crimes of the American Empire. Obama has proven that the vote is useless. Ralph Nader, Cornel West, Chris Hedges and many others are calling for such action. The connection between big oil and mindless war is well chronicled in Chalmers Johnson’s ‘The Sorrows of Empire’. This excellent indictment of American Exceptionalism will roil even the strongest stomach!