Montpelier 5/23/2012
It is forcast to be Chance of Rain at 11:00 PM EDT on May 23, 2012
Chance of Rain
73°/59°

Run of Site Leaderboard

twitter

4 responsesSubscribe to comments

  1. Hey Dan, you reported that the Governor said “I hope the Democrats will understand that the income and property tax structure in Vermont make competition difficult for Vermont businesses”

    did you or anyone else ask him to support that statement with evidence? or is it just received wisdom?

    by reporting these comments (ad nauseum) without challenging them, the media (including this site) leaves some readers with the impression that they are true; shouldn’t governors and other elected officials be held to a higher standard?

  2. Doug,

    Thank you writing with your critical thoughts regarding the report I wrote on the GOP state committee meeting. At this event, I listened, looked, reported what I saw. Indeed, communication with public officials needs to be 2-way, with tough questioning. For example, I was unable to confirm a statement by Gov. Douglas to the effect that the “Tax Foundation” reported Vermont’s overall tax burden is highest in the nation.

    I’ll be getting my questions ready and looking for my opportunity to ask them to people who should be answering. Keep your eyes out like this, and report problems where you see them, as you have done here, and you are providing a valuable public service, helping us all do a better job reporting.

    Thank you again,
    Dan Allen

  3. Dan,

    According to the US Census Bureau, Vermont is #1 in tax per capita as of 2005.

    http://www.census.gov/govs/statetax/05staxrank.html

    Great article, and I must say I’m impressed with the vision of the site in general. I’m very happy to see that a group of people are taking on this monumental task. It is MUCH needed.

    1. Dominic — As I said below, these figures are terribly misleading.

      First, you cited a per capita figure for “state” taxes. Have you forgotten that VT has a statewide tax for education? That means the total for state taxes in VT is much much higher than in other states where education taxes are local.

      If you combine state & local taxes, VT ranks 18th.

      Second, per capita taxes tells us nothing about the distribution of the so-called burden. It is a useless number. (do you know anyone named “per capita”?)

      Third, when you factor in VT’s comparatively progressive tax structure, taxes for Vermonters are in the middle of the pack. The only fair way to compare the tax “burden” is to ask what someone earning $30,000, $50,000, $100,000, or $1 million pays in every state. JFO did this for 12 states and debunked the myth that you are perpetuating.

      If we’re going to have a discussion about taxes, let’s make sure we’re using the relevant data and not cherry picking. We’ve had enough baloney from this governor and his friends.

Leave a Reply

Comment policy

VTD requires that all commenters identify themselves by first and last name. You may wonder why we don't accept anonymous comments. The short answer is: We want to keep the discourse civil.

You might rightly ask, since most online newspapers accept anonymous posts from readers, what makes VTD so special?

The long answer is: Anonymous comments don't support our mission. We are a nonprofit news organization dedicated to enhancing democracy through in-depth journalism. Our role is to foster a civil online discourse, and one very simple and effective way to do that is to require commenters to identify themselves. This isn't a new idea, of course. This is the way newspapers have treated letters to the editor since time immemorial.

As a result of our comment policy, VTD has created a safe zone for readers who want to engage in a thoughtful discussion on a range of subjects. We hope you join the conversation.

Privacy policy

VTDigger.org does not share specific information about our readers with other entities. Email addresses we collect through our subscription list and comment submissions are kept private.

We use Google analytics to generate aggregated data regarding the size and geographic distribution of our readership. This information helps us gauge how many readers come to the website and what towns they live in. It does not include addresses or other identifying characteristics about our readers.

Donate Today

We're an independent nonprofit organization, your donation helps fund the digging, and, it's tax deductible.

Thanks for reporting an error with the story, "Vermont GOP: Taxes, regulations hurt Vermont businesses, economy"