Courts & Corrections

UPDATED: Man allegedly kept body of missing woman in shed

missing woman
The scene in Poultney where a woman’s body was found Wednesday evening. Photo by Alan J. Keays/VTDigger

(This story was updated March 16 at 3 and 6:20 p.m.)

POULTNEY — Police say as they searched for several days for a missing Fair Haven woman, Wayne Oddo knew where she was and never said a word.

Oddo, 53, has not been charged in the death of Alexandra Rooker, 26, though he is being questioned in her disappearance. Federal prosecutors did charge Oddo on Thursday with being a drug user in possession of a firearm.

Police said they found Rooker’s body Wednesday evening on Oddo’s property on Morse Hollow Road in Poultney. She had been reported missing March 8 by family members who hadn’t heard from her since March 2.

Police said they discovered her remains in a shed a short distance from Oddo’s home when they raided the residence, armed with a federal search warrant.

Rooker reportedly was last seen March 3, when a friend dropped her off at Oddo’s home, federal prosecutors said in a statement late Thursday afternoon.

Alexandra Rooker
Alexandra Rooker. Photo courtesy of Vermont State Police

Preliminary autopsy results revealed no signs of trauma to Rooker’s body, with the cause and manner of her death still under investigation, said prosecutors. The time and date she died are still to be determined as well.

“This death is being treated as suspicious at this time and possibly related to a drug overdose,” prosecutors added in the statement.

During the past week, the statement said, Vermont State Police detectives interviewed Oddo as they tried to find Rooker. Oddo told detectives that Rooker had been at his residence but was no longer there.

“Perhaps most disturbing,” Assistant U.S. Attorney Nathanael Burris wrote in a court filing seeking to detain Oddo pending a trial, “the defendant was aware that the body of a deceased young female was wrapped in a tarp in a shed on the premises of his residence for approximately one full week, and yet took no action to alert law enforcement or medical personnel.”

“The level of disregard for human life inherent in this behavior is indicative of his dangerousness and the degree to which drug use is a motivating factor for the defendant’s action,” the prosecutor added.

Oddo made an initial appearance Thursday afternoon in federal court in Burlington. Magistrate Judge John Conroy ordered him detained pending a hearing March 24. At that hearing, Conroy is expected to rule on the prosecutor’s motion to detain Oddo until trial.

Federal prosecutors described both Rooker and Oddo as heroin users. Burris alleged that Oddo also was providing housing to people who sell deadly drugs.

“In the midst of this, he was in possession of various firearms,” Burris wrote. “The combination of these drugs and firearms is dangerous.”

If convicted on the firearms charge, Oddo faces up to 10 years in prison.

Oddo’s 2½-story home is on a dirt road about 4 miles from Route 140. Two troopers were at the scene Thursday morning providing security — one blocking a long driveway leading to the home and the other on the road looking down on the residence.

A state police crime scene vehicle was also parked in the driveway Thursday morning. There was little activity outside the home at that time, and no one was inside.

Sap collection lines ran across maple trees in the front of the property, and posted signs warned against going onto the land.

Detectives with the state police crime scene search team continued to process the scene Thursday afternoon. Joining state police in the investigation are the FBI and federal Bureau of Alcohol, Tobacco, Firearms and Explosives.

Federal prosecutors declined to comment Thursday. It was not immediately known if Oddo had an attorney.

Anyone with information about Rooker’s disappearance or death is asked to contact the Vermont State Police at 802-773-9101.

If you read us, please support us.

Comment Policy requires that all commenters identify themselves by their authentic first and last names. Initials, pseudonyms or screen names are not permissible.

No personal harrassment, abuse, or hate speech is permitted. Comments should be 1000 characters or fewer.

We moderate every comment. Please go to our FAQ for the full policy.

Alan J. Keays

Recent Stories

  • Neil Johnson

    Drugs are serious problem in Vermont, how much time, money and study is the legislature putting on this? Heroine….all the small towns know who’s dealing it.

    We spend all our time avoiding ethics, looking for a back door to legalize pot and frenzy our selves on a 90 day travel ban of 6 nations. Meanwhile we spend more than we take in a point fingers at the Governor for even suggesting a balanced budget. Drug addicted babies are born EVERY WEEK in Vermont.

    Yet our state has their hands tied, it always seems the feds are doing the arresting. We should hand cuff the criminals not our state police.

    We need to prioritize.

    • David Dudley

      Our legislators need to spend more time on a Carbon Tax…not worrying about this pesky drug problem……

      • Neil Johnson

        That’s hysterical, ….too funny. The best comedy has a kernel of truth, you hit a gold chunk.

    • Homer sulham

      Amen to that, you can’t fight a serious problem with lenient tactics.