Poirier mounts challenge for Speaker’s seat; Smith bristles at accusation he has squelched House debate

Paul Poirier, an independent state rep from Barre, will challenge Shap Smith, a Democrat, for his position as Speaker of the House. Poirier said he wants to rectify what he sees as a “total disregard of the views of the minority parties” under Smith’s command.

In a Nov. 11 interview with Mark Johnson, Poirer said he had been mulling over the thought of running since last spring, when, during floor debate about the Central Vermont Public Service Corporate-Green Mountain Power merger, he became dismayed by the lack of balance in the discussion and by Smith’s stalling tactics.

Listen to the podcast from The Mark Johnson Show.

“I’m disappointed by the lack of debate that we have on substantive issues,” Poirier said, pointing to the budget and tax issues as two topics that have not undergone sufficient discussion. “I come from the days when we had long vigorous debates.”

Poirier, first entered the Legislature in 1980 and once served as House Majority Leader under Speaker Ralph Wright.

Smith has been House Speaker since 2009 and a House member representing Elmore, Morrisville, Worcester and Woodbury since 2002.

Smith disagrees with Poirer’s assessment of his leadership. “I’m sorry Paul feels that way,” Smith said. “I don’t think that accurately characterizes what’s happening out there. I don’t think that’s borne out. Anyone who has watched floor has seen vigorous debates around health care, the budget, the energy bill, around vacciines.”

Smith said he wasn’t surprised by Poirier’s run, but the Speaker also isn’t taking any chances — he’s already called 80 lawmakers soliciting support.

The Speaker disputes the notion that he has squelched debate. “I guess everyone is entitled to have their own opinion,” he said. “In conversations I’ve had with people in running for Speaker again, people have told me they think I treat people fairly. We certainly have wide-ranging debates on the issues of the day.”

Poirier said he knows his odds aren’t good in a House where Democrats occupy 96 seats and Republicans, Progressives and independents collectively constitute 50 seats. But, Poirier said, in addition to courting the minority parties, he is “actively calling” a list of 25 Democrats who may be discontented enough with party dynamics to give Smith the boot.

Poirer said he also thinks House committees should be less dominated by Democrats, though he acknowledges the House constitution would constrain his ability to do so — “I can’t change the fact that there are 96 Democrats.”

Poirier said he was confident no other candidates would come forward, but Don Turner, Republican House Leader, didn’t rule out the possibility of a Republican bid for Speaker. Turner said this will be determined during the party’s caucus on Nov. 28.

Turner also acknowledged it would be difficult to dethrone Smith, but, he said, “I do think it’s important for the Speaker to know that not everyone is 100 percent happy with the way things have been going,” and, he added, “it will be healthy for the institution to have some challenge.”

The House will vote to select a Speaker on Jan. 9.

If you read us, please support us.

Comment Policy

VTDigger.org requires that all commenters identify themselves by their authentic first and last names. Initials, pseudonyms or screen names are not permissible.

No personal harrassment, abuse, or hate speech is permitted. Comments should be 1000 characters or fewer.

We moderate every comment. Please go to our FAQ for the full policy.

Privacy policy
Alicia Freese

Recent Stories

  • rosemarie jackowski

    I support Poirier. Change is good. Independent voices should be heard. End the D/R stranglehold.

  • Randy Koch

    Go Paul, go. The Smith-Shumlin Axis prevented adequate debate of the CVPS takeover even though it was the most important issue before the legislature for many decades. It was reported fairly decently in the press, was on the minds of many citizens, and Shap Smith smothered it. The speaker is an inherently tyrannical position but Shap has taken it much further than even Ralph Wright who, after all, needed to bring around the Republicans and blue dogs among his famous Hockey Team in order to get his way.

    If you win, give Shap to the old Ralph Wright treatment: chained to a lally column in the basement with food and water kicked in now and again.

  • Marty McMahon

    My recent contacts with Shap Smith confirm the need for Paul Porier. Smith’s irritation at any question he does not want to deal with and a studied arrogance ought to become clear as this moves forward.

  • walter moses

    He bristles, huh! Now is the time to get rid of this guy. E-mail, write or phone your representative and ask them to support Poirier for speaker. Time to get full debate instead of Shap’s ”care and feeding” of everything Shummy and his friends at GMP, Gaz Metro want. Time that this administration understands that Vermonters come first and Shummy’s friends in high places with big money do not run this state.

  • Townsend Peters

    Shap Smith was so intent on squelching debate on the CVPS-GMP merger that he ruled it was not “germane” to last year’s _energy_ bill. That’s open debate, eh?

    • Tim Cansfield

      Reminds me of the incident a few years back where the Fox News reporter was thrown out of the Statehouse for asking questions democrats didn’t like. And anyone familiar with these charlatans knows when they seek input for their committees it is only from people who agree with them. Liberty? We have about as much liberty as you can scratch on a aspirin with a crowbar. And now Sen. Leahy (is he senile?!) wants a law passed that allows the government to read our emails without a warrant. Seems like this liberty thing is just about over.

  • Nick Davlantes

    Go Paul and get Phil out of the equation as well. Thanks for sharing your ambitions.



    Yahoo! Its about time someone decided to Challenge Shap Smith!!! We someone who is Not going to walk the Governors Party line on taxes!!! Its time to raise revenue and fully fund the developmental services system to maximum capacity! NO MORE BUDGET CUTS IN AHS!!! TAX THE WEALTHY!!