Hoffer criticizes Salmon’s $5,000 payment of former campaign manager for health initiative

Candidate for state auditor Douglas Hoffer today criticized incumbent Thomas Salmon’s $5,000 payment to his former campaign manager for promoting a statewide health initiative, describing it as a “waste of taxpayer dollars.”

According to state financial data, the state auditor’s office paid $5,000 from the state’s general fund to John Kleinhans, in the financial quarter ending March 31, 2012. Kleinhans is in charge of the Accountable to You, Accountable to Me health program, which encourages Vermonters to give up alcohol, tobacco, and illegal substances, to lose weight, and to donate $2012 to a Vermont charity.

Asked why the relatively small payment of $5,000 is significant, Hoffer responded rhetorically: “So it’s OK to waste $5,000, as long as it isn’t $50,000 or $500,000? We shouldn’t be wasting any money at a time where there’s not much to go around.”

Salmon and Kleinhans didn’t return repeated requests for comment for this story.

Active in Republican political causes, Kleinhans has managed Salmon’s state auditor campaign in 2010, as well as Mark Snelling’s unsuccessful 2010 lieutenant governor campaign, according to his public LinkedIn profile. A former trustee of Vermont State Colleges, Kleinhans now works in Connecticut as a campaign manager for a U.S. congressional candidate.

Representatives at the state auditor’s office didn’t have information on how the initiative has fared at the time of press. Originally, the goal had been to sign up 1,000 Vermonters. Presently, however, the initiative’s Facebook page shows only 120 ‘likes’ and contains little other information on the initiative.

Tom Salmon, Vermont state auditor.

By Hoffer’s calculation, that’s a cost of over $40 per “like.” In a statement he said: “Ill-advised programs like this are one reason people get upset at government.”

Besides using social media on Facebook and Twitter, the initiative paired Vermonters with mentors to help them stick to their goals, and gave a monthly prize to a lucky contestant for submitting a personal story of “growth and transformation.” It isn’t known how much has been donated to Vermont charities to date thanks to this initiative.

Doug Hoffer. File Photo by Terry J. Allen

Hoffer emphasized that his criticism didn’t target Salmon personally, but that it was the first in an upcoming series of public criticisms of practices at the auditor’s office, which would show Hoffer’s “attention to detail” and ability to “ferret out” useful information. Salmon is not running for re-election. Hoffer’s opponent is state Sen. Vince Illuzzi, R/D-Essex-Orleans, a moderate Republican who has served in the state Senate for 32 years.

Hoffer also questioned why the state auditor’s office should participate in a health-related initiative, given its typical roles and responsibilities, but declined to say more about his general ongoing review of the auditor’s office, or his imminent criticisms in future weeks.

On the Facebook page’s Welcome section, user Wild Bill Goodhue writes of the program [sic]: “your not doing a very good job of getting the word out, no one I talk to has herd a thing , and I talk a lot.”

Correction: John Kleinhaus is no longer a trustee of the Vermont State Colleges. He completed a one-year term on June 30.

Nat Rudarakanchana

Comment Policy

VTDigger.org requires that all commenters identify themselves by their authentic first and last names. Initials, pseudonyms or screen names are not permissible.

No personal harrassment, abuse, or hate speech is permitted. Be succinct and to the point. If your comment is over 500 words, consider sending a commentary instead.

We personally review and moderate every comment that is posted here. This takes a lot of time; please consider donating to keep the conversation productive and informative.

The purpose of this policy is to encourage a civil discourse among readers who are willing to stand behind their identities and their comments. VTDigger has created a safe zone for readers who wish to engage in a thoughtful discussion on a range of subjects. We hope you join the conversation. If you have questions or concerns about our commenting platform, please review our Commenting FAQ.

Privacy policy
  • Neil Gerdes

    The more I learn about Doug Hoffer, the more I like him.

  • walter carpenter

    Yes, he is a great guy and is a genius in the confusing world of figures, percents, and numbers:)

  • Bob Stannard

    Doug would be a welcome relief to the current auditor.

  • Christian Noll

    I had the pleasure of meeting Doug just a few weeks ago and he was most helpful in explaining to me about how few Vermonters actually vote in the primary.

    Before speaking with Doug, I had no idea that fewer than 50,000 votes are cast in our primary. I would have thought more than that vote in our state.

    Based on Doug’s comments posted on vtdigger alone, I feel he is a strong candidate for the position of Vermont State Auditor. I’ve even put us a few of his lawn signs myself.

    Our state can only benefit from his service.

  • David Usher

    Perhaps there’s a story here hidden under a political candidate’s promotional opportunity?

  • Jason Farrell

    Check out Auditor Salmon in this episode of “Standing Watch”. Mr. Salmon goes to great lengths to describe his philosophy on what he believes the role of the Governor, the Legislature and the Office of the Auditor ought to be. When compared against this recorded dictum from months ago, Mr. Salmon’s conduct in handing tax-payer money over to his campaign manager appears abhorrently hypocritical.

  • Lance Hagen

    Mr. Hoffer had not problem defending the $8,500,000 grant to build the Vermont National Guard Solar Power Project. This is a project that never reaches a $ breakeven point before the solar panels reach their end of life. And now he is making a big fuss about $5,000.

    Talk about ‘Penny wish and pound foolish’.

    • David Bell

      “Talk about ‘Penny wish and pound foolish’.”

      I assume you meant wise?

    • Doug Hoffer

      Mr. Hagen

      At what point is OK to be concerned about waste? If $5,000 doesn’t get you going, how about $15,000? That’s what Mr. Salmon spent for an out of state firm (on a no bid contract) to offer suggestions for alternative revenue sources. One of the recommendations was to sell advertising space on state vehicles. Another was to sell the naming rights to state parks. All this in a state that outlawed highway billboards decades ago. Money well spent?

  • Stan Hopson

    Poor Mr. Hoffer, has to go after Salmon in lieu of something substantive about the position he wants o so badly.

    My advice Doug, please stop being so negative and unlikeable all the time, promote your self in a way enduring to Vermonters instead of the constant barrage of negativity.

    Unfortunately Iluzzi appears to have sewn the race up early with his bipartisan support.

Thanks for reporting an error with the story, "Hoffer criticizes Salmon’s $5,000 payment of former campaign manage..."