Police report shows blacks more likely to be stopped

Marty Tanner, a Burlington resident, talks about his experience with law enforcement. Photo by Anne Galloway

Marty Tanner, a Burlington resident, talks about his experience with law enforcement. Photo by Anne Galloway

An analysis of traffic stop data from four police departments in Chittenden County shows that blacks are more often stopped by law enforcement than their white and Asian counterparts.

The two-year study, spearheaded by a University of Vermont professor, shows that blacks are two times more likely to be to pulled over than whites in Burlington and South Burlington.

Data for the analysis was collected by four law enforcement agencies: Burlington, South Burlington, Winooski and the University of Vermont police departments. The information was gathered in 2009 and 2010.

Blacks in Winooski were 10 percent more likely to be stopped by the police. The pullover rate for blacks on the University of Vermont campus was 25 percent.

Read the report.

The police agencies began voluntarily collecting the data several years ago. The effort is an outgrowth of Uncommon Alliance, a nonprofit group that holds forums between community members and local police officers. The meetings are designed to ease tensions between the minority community and law enforcement. The alliance raised questions about racial and ethnic profiling by police and the courts and pushed for police training, new bias-free policing policies and a statistical analysis of racial disparities. This is the second year the local agencies have publicly disclosed race collection data.

Wanda Hines, founder of Uncommon Alliance. Photo by Anne Galloway

Wanda Hines, founder of Uncommon Alliance. Photo by Anne Galloway

Wanda Hines, one of the founders of Uncommon Alliance, said the coalition between communities of color and local law enforcement has led to an ongoing dialog and voluntary cooperation between the two groups.

“Uncommon Alliance efforts have created valuable trust where all voices have the opportunity to come to the table and be heard,” Hines said.

In other states, race data collection has been mandated by the courts or by statute. The four Chittenden County municipal police departments voluntarily began a statistical analysis of police practices in 2009. Each agency has also adopted bias-free policing policies and provided anti-discrimination training for officers.

The International Association of Chiefs of Police honored the four Chittenden County agencies with a civil rights award this year for their work with the community and self-reflective changes to standard operations.

Burlington Chief of Police Michael Schirling. Photo by Anne Galloway

Burlington Chief of Police Michael Schirling. Photo by Anne Galloway

Burlington Police Chief Michael Schirling hailed the release of the data as an important step toward eliminating racial bias in policing. He characterized the work with Uncommon Alliance as a solid foundation for building mutual trust between the community and law enforcement.

“The issue of race disparity in our country is one filled with passion and emotion and an extensive and often tragic history,” Schirling said. “Embedded in that history are images and stories of police the law enforcement of government and the entire criminal justice system being used as a direct instrumentality of racism and bias. Those images exist in stark contrast to the values of the justice system that we strive to uphold every day. Sadly this history tarnished the integrity of these critical institutions which exist to translate the ideal of equality before law into practice.”

Schirling eschewed the phrase “racial profiling.” His agency reviewed all arrests over the last two years and overt racism, he said, was not a factor for individual officers. Underlying racial biases, he said, subtly affect police work and accounts for the disparity in stop rates.

“Today, realizing that disparity continues to exist in the criminal justice system at all levels, we are committed to working tirelessly to both learn and distance ourselves from those historic events, to grow as a community as organizations and as individuals,” Schirling said.

In Burlington, black male drivers were stopped 307 times over the two-year period, while whites were pulled over 150 times. Blacks were twice as likely to be arrested.

In South Burlington, the stop rate disparity was even wider — 530 blacks and 263 whites were pulled over in the same time period. Blacks were six times more likely to be searched and five times more likely to be arrested than whites in the wealthy suburban city.

Read the joint statement from the four Chittenden County police chiefs.

Matty Tanner, a black Burlington resident and member of the alliance, told reporters at a press conference that race wasn’t a factor when he was growing up. Tanner had an idyllic childhood in Duxbury, he said, but once he got behind the wheel at age 16, he found he was treated differently than his white peers, even though he came from the same socioeconomic background. Tanner’s friend, Jose Perez, who also lives in Burlington, said he had been pulled over for traffic stops as many as 30 times in a single year.

“After a certain age, my experiences and those of my peers started to diverge in some instances,” Tanner said. “In school we were taught that every American is born with certain irrevocable rights related to the Constitution, and the exact limits to those right further articulated by the Supreme Court. These are all things I believed to be true right up until the time I became a black motorist.”

Tanner thanked police departments for addressing the issue “head on,” but he alleged that there is “a statistical racial bias throughout the criminal justice continuum,” and he made a reference to statistics that show higher rates of arrests and prosecutions for blacks and longer sentences for similar offenses and lower likelihood of parole.

“These figures (the Chittenden County data) finally will give a concrete voice to concerns I’ve been living with, concerns that up to now have largely been dismissed as anecdotal,” Tanner said.

If a bill now pending in the Legislature, H.535, is approved by the Senate and signed into law by the governor, all 73 local police agencies in the state will be required to collect race data.

The Vermont State Police began an analysis of traffic stop patterns last year. The state agency collects data on white and non-white stops. Under H.535, local law enforcement would develop a similar system.

Aggregated race data that doesn’t track traffic stops separately for Asians, Hispanics and blacks, may not provide a clear picture of police behavior, according to Robert Appel, executive director of the Vermont Human Rights Commission. That’s because Asians are only half as likely as whites to be stopped by police. Lumped together, the non-white data could be skewed as a result, he said.

Read the report.

Editor’s note: This story was updated at 6:56 a.m. April 3.

Anne Galloway

Comment Policy

VTDigger.org requires that all commenters identify themselves by their authentic first and last names. Initials, pseudonyms or screen names are not permissible.

No personal harrassment, abuse, or hate speech is permitted. Be succinct and to the point. Comments should be 1000 characters or fewer. If your comment is over 500 words, consider sending a commentary instead.

We personally review and moderate every comment that is posted here. This takes a lot of time; please consider donating to keep the conversation productive and informative.

The purpose of this policy is to encourage a civil discourse among readers who are willing to stand behind their identities and their comments. VTDigger has created a safe zone for readers who wish to engage in a thoughtful discussion on a range of subjects. We hope you join the conversation. If you have questions or concerns about our commenting platform, please review our Commenting FAQ.

Privacy policy
  • Alex Barnham

    I just wonder if the problem of police discrimination is handed to, promoted by, or otherwise condoned by the officers and their supervisors as an underlying rule or a bad attitude that has never been addressed. Obviously there is a problem and it is being addressed. That’s the GOOD NEWS.

  • Christian Noll

    The Burlington Police needs to have a specific and public process to bring about a formal complaint against a police officer.

    According to Lt. Stubbing of the BPD “There is no process for filing a complaint against a police officer.”

    I believe that there really IS a process but that the City of Burlington hires “Community Relations” officers to try and discourage complaints from being filed.

    This makes the City Attorney’s office look bad.

    Christian Noll
    BS/MS criminal justice

  • Christian Noll

    “Aggregated race data, that doesn’t track traffic stops for hispanic, asians and blacks and may not provide a clear picture of police behavior, according to Robert Apple, executive director of the Vermont Human Rights Commission.”

    Is an incomplete sentence.

    If you remove the word “and” between the words “black” and “may,” it would make it grammatically correct.

    As it stands now, it is an incomplete sentence.

  • Jim Candon

    It appears that Noll and Barham have made up their minds that police misconduct and discrimination are behind the numbers even though the study doesn’t answer the question of WHY. Before leaping to conclusions, why not continue the studies and find out why the disparitiyexist?

    • Christian Noll

      Jim thanks,

      The report was completed by two universities which don’t even offer studies nor have departments in criminal justice.
      So I find it interesting that you’d have an institution completing a report which is not exactly within the realm of their expertise.

      Sure I’m all for understanding “Why.”

      One of my points is that racial profiling is an old phenomena. It isn’t new at all.

      I think its great that we’re addressing this, but we’re only taking data from the police themselves and it only includes, “Traffic stops” or “Arrests.”

      Public citizens have been profiled by the police for decades and race is but only one of the ways they do so.

      My “Conclusion” is based on my many years of studying it as well as my own personal experiece as a victim.

      So yes Mr. Candon, lets “continue the studies and find out why the disparity exist.” I just don’t think you’ll like the results of what we find.

  • Alex Barnham

    If one looks carefully at the “tickets” given for vehicle and driving violations, they are “COMPLAINTS” filed by a police officer. As I understand the system, a policeperson is certified, trained, and sworn to tell the truth and thereby authorized to file a formal complaint. A citizen may also file a complaint but citizens do not have a legal pad of complaints printed by the State of Vermont and a process with which to file said complaint. That is lopsided justice wherever you stand on the issue of filing complaints.

    • Christian Noll

      Alex nice one and good catch.

      There should be a known and official process posted to the public on how one files a complaint against a particular officer or group of officers.

      Instead the Burlington Police Department has a specific officer assigned, usually under the title “Community Relations Officer” to try and disuade or discourage anyone from filing a complant, OR even knowing how to do so.

      In my case Lt. Stuebbing flat out denied knowing anything about how one files a complaint about police. She also seemed kind of aggitated and suspicious.

      The city of Burlington needs to be more responsible and open about this type of procedure. Trying to cover it up or deny that this process exists makes the police department look dishonest and unprofessional.

      I agree Alex, it IS “lopsided justice wherever you stand.”

Thanks for reporting an error with the story, "Police report shows blacks more likely to be stopped"