Rural Vermont responds to Common Cause Request from Green Mountain College

NEWS RELEASE

Nov. 14, 2012

Contact:
Andrea Stander
[email protected]
802-522-3284

Board of Directors and Staff join in supporting GMC’s principled stand
for food sovereignty
(see attached Op Ed)

Montpelier – The Board of Directors and staff of Rural Vermont
distributed an Op Ed (attached) today in support of Green Mountain
College’s (GMC) efforts to maintain their commitment to sustainable
agriculture and food sovereignty. Rural Vermont took the action in
response to a request for “Common Cause” support by Philip
Ackerman-Leist, Director of the GMC Farm & Food Project, Director of
the Masters in Sustainable Food Systems (MSFS) and Associate Professor
of Environmental Studies.

The request for Common Cause support was directed to the Vermont
agricultural community in the face of the overwhelming impact of
threatening tactics used by extreme animal rights groups who have been
attacking the college for decisions made by the entire GMC community
regarding the school’s aging team of oxen.

Rural Vermont has been a long-standing advocate for sustainable
agricultural practices that support our vision:

A local food system in Vermont which is self-reliant and based on
reverence for the earth. This system builds living soils which nurture
animals and people with wholesome, natural products supporting
healthy, thriving farms and communities. These communities in turn
work to encourage and support current and future farmers, continuing
our Vermont heritage. This abundant and generous way of life
celebrates our diversity and interdependence.

Rural Vermont fervently supports Green Mountain College’s right and
responsibility to make decisions regarding its farm operations and
farm animals according to its community’s values and needs. This is
exactly what they tried to do. Rural Vermont will continue to speak up
on behalf of the farmers who will feed us all.

OPINION

Dear Editor:

The recent controversy over the fate of Lou and Bill, an aged team of
working oxen at Poultney’s Green Mountain College, illustrates the
profound and dispiriting disconnect between contemporary American
society and the source of our food.

After announcing that Lou and Bill would be slaughtered for beef and
served in the school’s cafeteria, Green Mountain College became the
subject of rampant harassment, including a cyber-attack, on-line
bullying, and threats of physical violence. After weeks of bullying,
the college relented. Lou, who suffered from chronic injury, was
euthanized in cloak of night and under tight security; Bill will be
kept on at the college’s farm. Now the GMC students are left
questioning how to attain GMC’s stated goal to become the first
college or university in the United States with a major food service
provider to eliminate all animal products that are not humanely raised
and slaughtered, if they are not secure in making these decisions for
themselves.

No matter what one thinks of the college’s choices regarding Lou and
Bill, this episode is emblematic of our culture’s tragic desire to
remain unaccountable to the ramifications of how we feed ourselves.
Let us be clear: Truly sustainable agriculture and food production is
dependent on animals, not only for the nourishment of their meat and
milk, but also for the fertility of their manure, essential to the
production of the fruits, vegetables, and cereal crops upon which all
of us depend. Indeed, to erase animals from the cycle of agriculture
is to ensure dependence on fossil fuel-based fertilizers. Sustainable?
Not exactly.

We have suffered through multiple generations of agricultural and food
production opacity. The time has come for full accountability and
utter transparency regarding the most crucial, intimate exchange we
all engage in: Food. The time has come to acknowledge that our very
survival is dependent on the taking of life and to hold ourselves
fully accountable to this truth, difficult as it may sometimes be.
Green Mountain College set a strong example for all of us by having an
open community forum for students to come to a shared decision about
the fate of Bill and Lou. This shared decision-making is the essence
of food sovereignty – the freedom for communities to choose how they
will access their food according to their shared values and needs.

To be sure, there is no excuse for the deplorable conditions at large
scale meat production facilities. In fact, there is no excuse for
anything short of reverence for the animals that serve us. Lou and
Bill and every other creature that provides our nourishment – either
directly or indirectly – should be treated with the utmost respect.
And when the time comes to end their lives, as it inevitably will,
they deserve our deepest gratitude and the most humane slaughter we
can provide.

Rural Vermont has long stood for a community-based food system that
honors all its participants, including farmers, consumers, animals,
and the environment. Rural Vermont also stands with Green Mountain
College and the thousands of other Vermont farmers who acknowledge the
sometimes difficult realities of creating and maintaining healthy food
systems and who provide for their animals in a manner that honors
their critical role in our nourishment.

Rural Vermont Board of Directors and Staff
BOARD:
STAFF:

John Pollard – Shrewsbury
Andrea Stander – Montpelier

Lisa McCrory – Randolph
Shelby Girard – Brookfield

Ben Hewitt – Cabot
Robb Kidd – Montpelier

Carl B. Russell – Randolph
Mollie Wills – Middlesex

Doug Flack – Enosburg Falls

Tamara Martin – South Wheelock

Randy & Lisa Robar – South Royalton

Dexter Randall – Newport Center

Press Release

Leave a Reply

16 Comments on "Rural Vermont responds to Common Cause Request from Green Mountain College"

Comment Policy

VTDigger.org requires that all commenters identify themselves by their authentic first and last names. Initials, pseudonyms or screen names are not permissible.

No personal harassment, abuse, or hate speech is permitted. Be succinct and to the point. If your comment is over 500 words, consider sending a commentary instead.

We personally review and moderate every comment that is posted here. This takes a lot of time; please consider donating to keep the conversation productive and informative.

The purpose of this policy is to encourage a civil discourse among readers who are willing to stand behind their identities and their comments. VTDigger has created a safe zone for readers who wish to engage in a thoughtful discussion on a range of subjects. We hope you join the conversation.

Privacy policy
Sort by:   newest | oldest | most voted
3 years 8 months ago
The vast majority of the 50,000 people who signed the petition pleading for the lives of Bill and Lou to be spared made no threats of violence. GMC is overstating the case and using one or two threats that might have been made to gain sympathy and support. By and large, the animal rights community is a peaceful, nonviolent group of gentle, caring, compassionate people. We aim to STOP violence and suffering, not perpetuate it by killing and eating others. Any threats that were made came from those in the minority who feared the worst for Bill and Lou. Who… Read more »
Dawn Powell
3 years 8 months ago
This issue at Green Mountain College had nothing to do with food sovereignty. What actually happened was that the farm staff and administration announced that they were going to slaughter both oxen due to Lou’s injury, and serve ’em up, the students, alumni and surrounding community were outraged. Bill and Lou went to community events. The students loved them. So a farm sanctuary offered to take them. The 3 men refused. They wanted to kill them. So people offered a lot of money to buy them and send them to sanctury. They offered treatment for Lou’s foot. The 3 men… Read more »
Judith Romeo
3 years 8 months ago

This article mentions “utter transparency”. I couldn’t agree more. Let’s stop hiding slaughter behind closed doors. Let the public see where their sirloin and lamb chops are really coming from. They had a face. Let’s see it!

Michael Colby
3 years 8 months ago

Thank you to Rural Vermont for standing up and speaking out on this issue.

Grace Gershuny
3 years 8 months ago

Thank you, Rural Vermont. I am proud to be a member and former Board member.

Eric Rosenbloom
3 years 8 months ago

The issue of animals in agriculture has nothing to do with the public outrage over GMC’s determination to kill their well known and loved oxen. Rural Vermont (the organization) seems to share Ackerman-Leist’s paranoia that any criticism is essentially a terrorist attack on a whole way of life.

Yet it is precisely the college’s inhumane refusal to consider retirement for their oxen — despite offers of sanctuary and even money — that shines a bad light on animal agriculture.

Eric Rosenbloom
3 years 8 months ago

Also, it is utter nonsense that animals are essential to food production. Obviously they are essential to meat and milk production, but those are not essential. And their manure mostly supports the grain used to feed them, not humans. Crop rotation, cover crops, combination planting, etc. — farming without animal products AND without chemicals has been practiced for centuries.

3 years 8 months ago

The only violence committed was by the college. They refused peaceful sanctuary offers.

3 years 8 months ago

Eric Rosenbloom is correct. For instance, European explorers were impressed with the productivity of the Indian’s farms. They did not use domesticated animals. Even if we did need more animal manure, we don’t need to kill them to get that.

The college seems to be tripping over itself inventing one lie after another, rather than admitting that killing animals for food has become unjustifiable on ethical, fiscal, and sustainability grounds in modern society. (I would bet the entire board buys factory farm products, too.)

Rebecca Stucki
3 years 8 months ago
“To be sure, there is no excuse for the deplorable conditions at large scale meat production facilities. In fact, there is no excuse for anything short of reverence for the animals that serve us. Lou and Bill and every other creature that provides our nourishment…should be treated with the utmost respect.” No excuse, except for the ones we keep getting that humans MUST eat animal products to survive, and the fact that any commodification of animals on any scale will result in commodification on a large scale in order to satisfy the world’s appetite for flesh. And if by “utmost… Read more »
Christy Slate
3 years 8 months ago

Thank you Rural Vermont Board of Directors and Staff for publicly standing with Green Mountain College.

peter harvey
3 years 8 months ago
I have never before been the victim of such a vicious militant assault as has happened over the last several weeks. Call it what it is. If I treated my cows, pigs, and chickens the way these militants are treating farmers I would be shunned by my neighbors. Instead I am feeding my neighbors. In response, either I shrink to submit to the force of their anger or be brave enough to stand my ground against them. I choose to make my own decisions within the recognized conventions of our society. In my end, I do hope to be treated… Read more »
Ana Stolof
3 years 8 months ago
I am very saddened to see you stand up and support GMC in this — it has all been appalling, their refusal to look at any other way but their own. Their methods are NOT sustainable, they are NOT models for the WORLD….they are just a small college in Vermont who knew they could get support to kill their draft animals if they went this route. I am appalled that they would not let Bill and Lou go retire to a sanctuary and would not let Lou get top medical. He was viewed as meat instead and so did not… Read more »
pat white
3 years 8 months ago
GMC sent out a form letter? We all need to remember that a GMC student contacted GMAD that in turn contacted VINE. GMC admits that Lou was in ‘obvious pain’, so why did they keep him alive from summer to the fall? Meat animals are not legally able to be drugged does this include pain medication? What is the withdrawel time frame? Although the CAFOs seem to be able to use arsenic and antibiotics, excuse me growth regulators. GMC is no better then the CAFOs that we attempt to avoid, that use cattle prods to force an animal to be… Read more »
Catie Hanks
3 years 8 months ago

Green Mountain College is a disgrace and so are you Rural Vermont.

Michele Poling
3 years 8 months ago
Rural Vermont really, open up your minds…when I first started reading about this I thought that college was horrible…I have read the newsletters, and checked out all the information including financial status. They seem to treat their animals with love and I truly enjoyed reading their animal updates. The college gave Bill and Lou personality, and I loved seeing them hug on the kids at the school, they just seemed like very special oxen, and I hate that they were going to be slaughtered..special circumstances could have been deemed, I personally don’t believe from the press statement that the college… Read more »
wpDiscuz
Thanks for reporting an error with the story, "Rural Vermont responds to Common Cause Request from Green Mountain Co..."