- VTDigger - http://vtdigger.org -
Exempt your state university and its donors from open-records laws? Here’s what you get
Posted By VTD Editor On March 6, 2010 @ 3:45 pm In Education | 9 Comments
Eugene, ORE. — Sunshine is a virtue in most every field of human endeavor, but possibly nowhere more so than in the realms of architecture and law.
When designing new buildings, architects typically strive to admit as much natural light as possible because human beings are known to thrive in such conditions. When designing instrumentalities of government, lawmakers seek to build notions of accountability and openness into the organizational structure because, as Louis Brandeis famously observed, sunshine is the best disinfectant.
Louis Brandeis would likely have an aneurism if he ever visited the University of Oregon (UO) in Eugene.
Driving into town along Franklin Boulevard, and arriving on the campus, three things are immediately striking. One is a brand new rectangular building, clad almost entirely in glass. In fact, the building has an inner and an outer sheet of glass, between which is an insulating layer of air and a skrim of stainless steel strands that allow just enough light to make the interior spaces pleasant. This is the classic Miesian box, updated for 21st Century energy efficiency imperatives, two sides of which seemingly float on a placid reflecting pool, constructed in every respect with the most expensive possible materials and craftsman ship.
Though this remarkable building looks like it might be a library for rare books, or perhaps an art museum, or maybe even the denizen of some lucky university bureaucrats, the actual program, revealed in freestanding metallic lettering at curbside, is astonishing. The Jaqua Academic Center for Student Athletes is 40,000 square feet of special help for jocks, designed by the prominent Seattle architecture firm Zimmer Gunsul Frasca.
A few hundred feet away is a vast construction site, featuring a gigantic building with impressive trusses still visible from the sidewalk as of March. It is a new basketball arena that, from the standpoint of size, would rival anything that houses an NBA team. Welcome to the world of athletics in the NCAA’s high-powered Pacific-10 Conference.
The third striking object, as one arrives at the university, is not visible until one turns around and faces north. It is a billboard, the top of which shouts: “Respect Public Records Laws.” Beneath this are the words “UO Arena Project” and, below that, “www.nobidcontracts.org .”
Eugene therefore should be a mandatory field trip for Vermont lawmakers who are voting this very Tuesday on a bill that would exempt certain records of the University of Vermont, and other state-owned institutions of higher education, from Vermont’s public records statute. At issue are records relating to the schools’ private donors.
Donors are definitely driving the bus at UO, a campus that is gradually becoming a sprawling athletic complex with a few academic out-buildings appended thereto. As the billboard suggests, university officials commissioned the Knight Arena behind closed doors, using money donated by alumnus and Nike shoe mogul Phil Knight. His donative inclinations are also what bankrolled the opulent tutoring center – indeed, a looming image of his face, etched in mirrored glass, decorates two bathrooms. What’s odd is that they’re women’s bathrooms.
What was the budget of this high-gloss building? University officials have steadfastly declined to say, according to the local papers. One low-level employee from the facilities department mentioned the figure of $20 million to The Oregonian.
Down Franklin Boulevard, the $200 million Knight Arena will accommodate more than 12,000 spectators. Eugene had a population of roughly 138,000, according to the 2000 Census. Imagine a public university with the pluck to build a basketball court that can welcome nearly 10 percent of its host city’s population and you get a sense of what the University of Oregon is all about.
TVA Architects in Portland designed the Knight Arena in cooperation with Ellerbe Beckett, the mega-firm that designed the homes of the Atlanta Braves, the Arizona Diamondbacks, the NBA’s San Antonio Spurs, and the NFL’s Seattle Seahawks, among lots of others. According to the Oregon Daily Emerald, it will be the nation’s most expensive basketball arena.
Eugene therefore should be a mandatory field trip for Vermont lawmakers who are voting this very Tuesday on a bill that would exempt certain records of the University of Vermont, and other state-owned institutions of higher education, from Vermont’s public records statute.
The “no bid contracts” web site is the work of something called the Foundation for Fair Contracting, funded by a group of contractors and labor unions, including the Teamsters. According to their web site, “Our concern is not with the basketball arena, but rather the process by which $200 million of bonds (backed by the full faith and credit of the state of Oregon) were spent through a questionable use of an emergency declaration, special procurement and sole source procurement that exist exclusively for the Oregon University System” under Oregon law.
Their web site complains that an open-records request for the contracting documents was rejected. When the planning process began seven years ago, the university’s president noted that, because the school and its donors created a separate, and private, nonprofit organization to build the project, public scrutiny would be limited.
It would be improvident for a visitor from Vermont (in town to attend an environmental law conference at UO’s law school) to speculate on the merits of these controversies. But two realities emerge.First, the Jaqua Center is a stunning work of contemporary architecture – the very embodiment of the reality that true simplicity is both beautiful and expensive. The second is that this orgy of athletic construction, at a school where NCAA competition seems to trump all, appears to be unfolding beyond the realm of public accountability.
Attention Vermont Legislature: This is what happens when state-supported educational institutions are allowed to raise and spend tens if not hundreds of millions of dollars behind tightly shut doors. Vermont’s state-supported institutions of higher education still put academics first. But when donors call the shots, doing so outside the normal requirements of public scrutiny, athletic boosterism can too often become the driving strategic priority.
And the result? A $20 million study hall.
Article printed from VTDigger: http://vtdigger.org
URL to article: http://vtdigger.org/2010/03/06/exempt-your-state-university-and-its-donors-from-open-records-laws-here%e2%80%99s-what-you-get/
URLs in this post:
 Image: http://vtdigger.org/vtdNewsMachine/wp-content/uploads/2010/03/kriesbillboard.jpg
 Want a liquor license? Take our virtual polygraph test: http://vtdigger.org/2010/08/31/want-a-liquor-license-take-our-virtual-polygraph-test/
 Vermont Yankee and the perils of PowerPoint postscript: http://vtdigger.org/2010/05/15/vermont-yankee-and-the-perils-of-powerpoint-postscript/
 Vermont Yankee’s Earth Day gift sets a troubling precedent: http://vtdigger.org/2010/04/24/vermont-yankees-earth-day-gift-sets-a-troubling-precedent/
 Vermont architecture: The get-lost effect gets recognized: http://vtdigger.org/2010/04/17/vermont-architecture-the-get-lost-effect-gets-recognized/
 Vermont as the Delaware of low profit: A skeptic’s view: http://vtdigger.org/2010/02/22/vermont-as-the-delaware-of-low-profit-a-skeptics-view/
 Not so fast: N.Y. Public Service Commission didn’t reject Entergy proposal; it merely steered middle ground: http://vtdigger.org/2010/02/13/not-so-fast-n-y-public-service-commission-didnt-reject-entergy-proposal-it-merely-steered-middle-ground/
 It can’t happen here? Deadly power plant explosion on the Connecticut: http://vtdigger.org/2010/02/08/it-can%e2%80%99t-happen-here-deadly-power-plant-explosion-on-the-connecticut/
 www.nobidcontracts.org: http://www.nobidcontracts.org/
 Image: http://vtdigger.org/vtdNewsMachine/wp-content/uploads/2010/03/kriesbuilding.jpg
 Image: http://vtdigger.org/vtdNewsMachine/wp-content/uploads/2010/03/kriesbuilding2.jpg
 : http://www.salon.com/opinion/conason/2010/03/05/mcconnell/
Copyright © 2011 VTDigger. All rights reserved.